Aruba: Natalee Holloway: Deepak & Satish Kalpoe Suing Dr Phil for Defamation … Doesn’t One Have to First have Character?


Can people who knowingly and willfully lie, obstruct justice and bear false witness have the credibility to sue for defamation? Doesn’t one first need character in order to sue for it’s damage? The Kalpoe’s and Aruba have been dancing around the truth in the Natalee Holloway case for 3 years running. The question that needs to be addressed is did either Deepak or Satish Kalpoe have the ability to sue for libel seeing that their reputations were already tarnished prior to the Dr Phil tape. Namely, their reputations were tarnished by their own doing. By the way, why does one wash their car in the middle of the night? A car that Natalee Holloway was last seen in and never was heard from again?


Satish, Deepak and Dr. Phil

The defamation lawsuit filed by the two Surinamese brothers, Deepak and Satish Kalpoe, against Dr. Phil McGraw and CBS over a broadcast concerning the disappearance of Natalee Holloway continues to go forward. The first question that one would ask is, how can one claim defamation of charters if they are void of said character? Should the law suit go forward? Probably not; however, I say why not … discovery and interrogatories of the Kalpoe brothers might just be what the doctor ordered to help find answers and “Justice for Natalee”.

A lawsuit filed in December 2006 by Surinamese brothers Deepak and Satish Kalpoe maintains they were defamed in a Sept. 15, 2005, “Dr. Phil” show, when it was alleged they gave Holloway a date-rape drug and had non- consensual group sex with her. They also contend the episode implied they helped kill Holloway and dispose of her body.


What did they know and when and why did they lie?

The “Dr. Phil” segment included statements by Deepak Kalpoe that were “significantly manipulated and altered,” the suit alleges. In addition to defamation, the Kalpoes’ suit alleges invasion of privacy, emotional distress, fraud, deceit and civil conspiracy.

But in court papers filed Wednesday, attorneys for CBS, McGraw and Kay Skeeters — widow of Jeremy Skeeters, a private investigator hired by McGraw to interview Deepak Kalpoe — maintain the brothers are “libel-proof.”

They say the brothers’ reputations were irreparably stained by prior published accounts of the Holloway case, meaning they cannot claim to have been damaged by the “Dr. Phil” broadcast.

Satish Kalpoe’s June 24, 2005 important and must read statement

Read all of the suspect & witness statements HERE and HERE

What reputation does one have when they continually lie in witness statements and provide constant inconsistencies in their stories?

One needs to ask themselves, what reputation did the Kalpoe’s have prior to the Dr. Phil report other than that of suspects in the murder of Natalee Holloway and admitted liars? The Kalpoe’s were last seen leaving Carlos N’ Charlies with Natalee Holloway along with Joran Van der Sloot, Natalee was never seen again. It was also the Kalpoe’s that were complicit in the lie that they dropped off Natalee Holloway that night at the Holiday Inn and subsequently implicated two black security guards for her disappearance.

The position of the Dr. Phil defense attorneys is as follows:

The brothers also did not ask for a correction of the “Dr. Phil” broadcast in time and are limited public figures, meaning they have to prove malice by CBS and the other defendants, the defense attorneys argue.

The defense attorneys have a motion pending Aug. 5 to dismiss the case on grounds the plaintiffs’ lawyers disobeyed court orders to turn over information.

If you liked this post, you may also like these:

  • Dr. Phil Attorneys Use Scared Monkeys Natalee Holloway Posts as Exhibit in Court Docs Against Deepak & Satish Kalpoes
  • Natalee Holloway: Deepak & Satish Kalpoe Mislead the Court & Continue with VISA Excuses to Dodge Depositions in LA County, CA Dr Phil Defamation Case
  • Diario: Satish Kalpoe and his lawyer Invited to comment on Deepak recording
  • Joran, Deepak, Satish … No Soup for You. Three Suspects Remain Suspects in Aruba
  • Dr Phil’s Response to Kalpoe Defamation Law Suit … Character, what Character?

  • Comments

    38 Responses to “Aruba: Natalee Holloway: Deepak & Satish Kalpoe Suing Dr Phil for Defamation … Doesn’t One Have to First have Character?”

    1. Carpe on June 14th, 2008 1:01 pm

      Please, do not put our sweet Natty girl in a
      juxtaposition shot in the middle of those two stinky butt ferret, Kalpoe turd burglars!!!

      It gets my thing all cinched up in a knot.

      It’ll take a week to undo it.


    2. tuyvnsurvivor on June 14th, 2008 2:49 pm

      I watched Dr Phil years ago and felt he was full of himself. No more right than a Pinto.

      Perhaps in his defense per this matter, it seems he was reporting and concerting with the entire hearing and reading public. He never was leading. And he reported with the same explotation and shock which made him stink in all his tradition. Wrestling Phil

    3. murph on June 14th, 2008 2:52 pm

      Hey Deepak,
      I know you and Satish cannot get a girl unless you drug them. I want to be honest here and just say it- you need some money to buy yourself a girl, because the both of you are so greasy looking, you know, nasty as hell. Back to suing for some dosh, well Dr. Phill’s attorney’s will chew you up and spit you out. Hey Joran is naked in
      Thailand, but doesn’t need you for a driver anymore, so better come up with a new plan!
      Hey, how is that book deal going. What a pair of IDIOTS!!!!!!!!!

    4. Tamikosmom on June 14th, 2008 3:07 pm

      Klaas … please check that default file. It appears my submission has got sidetracked.

      Thank you.

      SM: Janet – I don’t see anything of yours in the spam folder right now, you may need to resubmit. Sorry about that! (klaasend)

    5. Tamikosmom on June 14th, 2008 3:14 pm

      I have learned that under Dutch law the case files related to an open investigation cannot be released and … when it is considered that Hans Mos claims the investigatin is ongoing …

      However .. The televised words of the Deputy Chief and … the official statements released to the media by the prosecutor’s office pertaining to the “suspicions” encompassing the arrest and the rearrest of Deepak and Satish … defamed these guys prior the airing of the … now enfamous … Dr. Phil Show.

      Can these transcripts/videos of televised interviewed as well as the official statements released to the media … be requested by Phil McGraw’s attorneys as evidence?



      Gerold Dompig
      October 12, 2005

      So sometimes people will ask us that, “Are you not tunnel-visioned? Maybe you should look at other possibilities.” Of course. We did that. But we still feel that, every time you go on a path, a different path, that path leads back, comes back to these three boys.


      Gerold Dompig
      ‘Rita Cosby Live & Direct’
      November 2, 2005

      COSBY: Do you believe, Chief—you said to me even before this interview that you believe the boys are guilty as hell. Do you believe they‘re involved in her disappearance?

      DOMPIG: Yes.


      Gerold Dompig
      ‘Rita Cosby Live & Direct’
      November 8, 2005

      DOMPIG: I still believe that these boys have been lying, they’re still lying, and everybody knows that by now. So there’s no doubt in my mind that they know something, they’re guilty of something.


      Gerold Dompig
      November 12, 2005

      DOMPIG: Exactly. And I go by the rule of thumb that, in the first 40 days — as I said in a different program — the first 40 days, law enforcement has probably also already spoken to the perpetrators. So we feel strongly that we have already spoken to them. And there’s no one else outside this group that could be involved or responsible.



      Brothers arrested again in Aruba case
      Two held on suspicion of acting with others in teen’s rape, killing
      Saturday, August 27, 2005

      (CNN) — After being detained and then released last month in Natalee Holloway’s disappearance, two brothers were arrested again Friday in Aruba on suspicion they acted “together with other people” in raping and killing the Alabama teen, the prosecutor’s office said …

      “They are suspected of the primary criminal act of together with other people committing premeditated murder, alternately together with other people murdering somebody, more alternately rob a person of her liberty with fatal consequences and even more alternately raping somebody,” the statement said.


    6. Paulus is a FAT EVIL UGLY PIG on June 14th, 2008 3:20 pm

      anita must be proud of her delicious sporter

      anita is a joke

    7. Carpe on June 14th, 2008 3:24 pm


      “Hey, how is that book deal going. What a pair of IDIOTS!!!!!!!!!”


      Murph, you are so sharp, I’m very surprised that
      you missed that one!

      Dirt-pock already put his book out already!!!

      I am supplying a link, to show you how it is currently ranked on the NY TIMES BEST SELLERS LIST.

    8. Allan on June 14th, 2008 3:48 pm

      Undoubtedly these rapists, accessory to murder pin heads haven’t a moral bone in their body. somebody needs to put a stop to trash like this. Anything this ludicrous should never even go to court.

    9. richard on June 14th, 2008 4:05 pm

      Is there any evidence to show that they were NOT involved in Natalee’s death and in the disposal of her body? Certainly from day one, they were over there at the van der Scum compound … and PvdScum at first even paid for their lawyer.

      If their case against Dr. Phil is dismissed, what happens to the countersuit that I believe he filed? The Kalpoes started the trouble … I hope that he finishes it.

    10. Maggie on June 14th, 2008 7:35 pm

      One only has to read their statements and watch their behaviour the last 3 years to know they don’t appear to have any character to start with. Even the mother, who asked that they not air the tape of her on Dr. Phil, because she blew her son’s timeline. I remember reading too a story about the mom Nadira being fired for stealing from her job. Prior to Dr. Phil, Joran said in his statements that Deepak raped and buried Natalee by the fisherman’s huts.

      Prior to the date of Natalee being in Aruba, Hans Mos said they found chat sessions of these guys discussing getting american tourist girls and what they planned to do with them. I think they call that premeditated, except in Aruba. Defammation of character..what a joke.

    11. brie. on June 14th, 2008 9:08 pm

      A couple of freaks and their sex mobile…..should of stayed in Suriname….worthless pieces of crap…I hope Dr. Phil cleans your closet and Aruba puts out the no welcome sign…….Natalee lost her life and you WANT financial gain…!!!!!

    12. A New Girl on June 14th, 2008 10:50 pm

      Deepak Kalpoe is evil. Very bitter, any observer could tell by just listening to his own words and saying Natalee looked like/dressed like a “slut”, and she wanted it, etc. Are you serious? What a give-away right there!

      Total misfits of society, and Satish is the weakling, just following his older brother around. They both suck, and I am glad their name is dirt. They’ll pay for the implication of their crimes against an innocent victim forever. They all lie–even the demented Sporter laughed about how stupid they were and admitted to using them.

      I hope the case gets thrown out of court. Rapists and acessories to murder deserve every bit of nastiness they get.


    13. murph on June 15th, 2008 7:16 am

      Carpe#7- Thanks for the heads up on the bottle fart book- I missed that one. Dee-punk should be very good at putting farts in a bottle.These guys are such losers! We have Joran naked in Thailand and the Kalpoe’s trying to cash in on the Killing of Natalee. I am waiting for justice to prevail with these scumbags, but no matter, because these killers will strike again ,and someone will take care of this problem!!

    14. brie. on June 15th, 2008 7:56 am

      If Dr Phil has filed a countersuit against the Kalpoe weasels maybe the truth will have to come out…tell us Deepak how did Natalee fall and hit her head and why were you washing your car at 3AM….and tell us Satish what was the “something bad happened” that you spoke of…..??????

      Maybe they would have to come to the US and face our court system…..

      I bet Paulus and Joran are wondering how this is going to turn out…..

    15. SS on June 15th, 2008 9:44 am

      Deepak and Satish – It looks like your lawsuit is on it’s way down the hopper. If you are as innocent as you profess to be, now is the time to step up to the plate. Your friend Urine has sold you out and he has tired to blame you for Natalee’s demise. He has no conscience and he is off playing in his narcassistic world of greed and disgust. It’s time for you two to come forward and tell the world what really happened that night. If you weren’t part of it, then clear your names while you still have a fragment of a name to clear. Do the right thing and come forward with the truth. Your selfish exploits have caused harm to an entire island. Make things right and tell the truth. If you remain silent, you deserve all that comes your way.

    16. kayjay on June 15th, 2008 9:49 am

      Early on in Natalee’s case I think I read or heard somewhere that the Kalpoes were born in Surinam, and either one or both had criminal records in their own country….in any event their bad characters have been well proved since and they deserve everything they get as I am sure Dr. Phil’s lawyers will leave them twisting in the wind, hopefully for the buzzards to get to.

    17. MissKatie on June 15th, 2008 10:12 am

      I find this law suit against Dr. Phil outragious.. what’s wrong with our system in this case..

      That they will profit from a crime they comitted come on!!!

      Everyone on that island presents as money hungry slobs…
      like in the case where when dave went to talk to the police… they had the nerve to ask how much money he had…

      they are money hungry …. I wished there some loop hole where they couldnt collect!!!

      ITS NOT RIGHT!!!!

    18. MissKatie on June 15th, 2008 10:22 am

      LOL BRIE


    19. MissKatie on June 15th, 2008 10:25 am


      I read that they were throwed out of their country for a similar crime against a female there..

    20. MissKatie on June 15th, 2008 10:32 am

      every time I see a picture of those two brothers pop up my blood boils!!!

      they should turn on joran after all he and his dad hold no loyalty to them…

      for a time there remember?? that pauulus was grooming joran for a law suit….until the tapes came out!!

      even patrick and peter cashed in on his tragedy!!!

    21. david r on June 15th, 2008 2:02 pm

      I think MissKatie is right. The Kalpoe boys could make a bundle “seetling” with Dr. Phil after they give up Paulus. They’d get their money, Dr. Phil would get his ratings, and we’d get Paulus’ head on a pole. Are you listening boys ? Opportunity knocks. After all, a few years down the road you’ll still be just be a couple of poor Arubans looking for a cheap score. Sell out Paulus and live like kings.

    22. MissKatie on June 15th, 2008 4:50 pm

      david r

      Dr. Phil is disgusting.. he had them on for the ratings.. and it back fired on him.. but even so I just dont think that the kalpoes should cash in on a crime they helped commit…
      the only reason they dont turn joran in is that.. they dont want to scew up chances to get their hands on all that money…
      did you hear that the kalpoes mother had lost her job for stealing from her job.. whatever her job was!!
      I cannot wait till we see some kind of sign that the tables are turned in the sense that they slip up and get caught.

      but chances are that while on the island of aruba they have full protection.. the female victims are considered the perpetrators isnt that bazaar… aruba continues to believe the criminal.. I think that the criminals in aruba pay for charges to be dropped.
      even women raped on the island
      even they are victimized…
      I just get sick that Justice isnt fast enough
      but soon …I hope real soon….

    23. david r on June 15th, 2008 8:49 pm

      Now that the truth about Aruba is out, I’m sure many of the Mountain Brook group, like people from all over the country, are amazed that they ever wanted to go there in the first place. We need to continue to warn American women how they are fair game in Aruba, where the police are indifferent and the government in the hands of the tourism industry.

    24. Carpe on June 16th, 2008 11:07 am


      Character, folks. That’s what life is all about.

      When I think of honor, valor, and integrity…

      I think Deepak & Satish Kalpoe… or as I like

      to so lovingly call them at times,

      > Simon & Buttfunkle.

    25. Sharon Chicago on June 16th, 2008 11:12 am

      They both are guilty just like Joran. They were involved and they are evil like Joran! Paulus
      will make sure that these two take the rap for his son Joran if it ever comes down to the truth of Jorans guilt in a a court.

    26. misskatie on June 16th, 2008 3:23 pm

      those two bugged eyes kalpoes idiots are hanging a low profile for something… think about it..
      they arent going to do anything to jeopordize their law suit against Dr. Phil.. clear across the ocean these idiots and their lawyers are already smelling the scent of money!!!!

      they are as guilty as joran and pauulus and your right pauulus would fix it to where they would go to jail for natalees death… so that his son can could continue to take advantage of women.. he is narcisistic

    27. misskatie on June 16th, 2008 4:50 pm

      satish is a bish

    28. misskatie on June 16th, 2008 5:00 pm

      if you know what I mean!!!

    29. molly in houston on June 16th, 2008 9:46 pm

      New show on tv……”ARUBA’S DUMBEST CRIMINALS”
      Starring…..the Kalpoop Brothers……yay!
      Sponsored by Dumbpigs and VenerealDiseaseSloot

      boycott aruba
      molly in houston

    30. MissKatie on June 17th, 2008 2:21 pm

      lol molly

    31. kaye on June 18th, 2008 7:22 am

      kalpoes………i know you’re reading here. It’s the $$$$$ you’re after….it’s simple…spill your guts, you’ll be celebrities, talk shows, magazine and movie deals, collect the money, move to another country and live happily ever after……….

    32. misskatie on June 18th, 2008 7:22 pm


      The kalpoes dusgust me .it infuriates me that they are trying to cash in on a death they were involved in comitting. they helped rape and kill natalee guilty guilty and they know it… no matter how hard they try that will never change .. they will never be able to forget what they did…with alot of money or no money…… they arent innocent.. just because they are hanging a low profile…

      but they know about karma.. and it will rain hard on them because thats blood money… I hope they have nightmares.. they like joran have no concious or heart… it must be the society they came from and of course the way they too were raised.. they were raised poor so of course they are going to try to get rich … but it wont last they are taking money that they have no right to.. karma will catch up with them and we will all sit back and enjoy seeing what comes their way!!!

      dunno who will get theres first wether it will be joran first … or possibly pauulus… or satish first or even deepak first … lets not exclude their parents… theres enough karma to go around for all the evil doe’rs … enjoy your time now because soon you will see things falling apart…
      nothing is forever…. god doesnt bless evil with lots of money… doesnt work that way…

      alot of people sell their soul to the devil for alot of money
      but it wont last
      wether you sold your sold your soul for 10 or 20 yrs..
      it goes by fast
      than one day your time has expired….

      the devil doesnt want you he just wants your soul

      u belong to him now

    33. misskatie on June 18th, 2008 7:25 pm

      theres only one way out
      and thats to come clean and tell what realy happened .. god is a forgiving god.. but if you continue in the path your on now.. you wont be able to turn back…

    34. Dr. Phil Attorneys Use Scared Monkeys Natalee Holloway Posts as Exhibit in Court Docs Against Deepak & Satish Kalpoes | Scared Monkeys on July 12th, 2008 6:24 pm

      [...] many have stated since the Kalpoe’s filed their defamation law suit, how can one have their character impugned if there was no character or reputation in the first place? From the outset of the Natalee Holloway disappearance and the case against the three main suspects, [...]

    35. Eileen Wolf on November 24th, 2008 11:08 pm

      So, what happens with this lawsuit after Greta’s interview with Joran that aired tonight, Nov. 24th? Joran claims he and the Kalpoe boys sold Natalee to ‘someone’ and she was taken to Venzuela. Will their claims of defamation… beleieved when everyone knows tha truth aobut how Joran father paid off two or three police in Aruba…. maybe even Hans Mos? I wonder how Jorans father feels abouer Joran finaly telling the truth about what he did to Natalee…. after Daddy paid off so many people! There are also three phone calls between Daddy and son…..

    36. melisa stolzenburg on March 20th, 2009 2:28 am

      only God knows the truth and when judgement day cimes whoever you are will face Him …and unless you confess now and take your measly punishment ..
      it is nothing compared to eternal hell fire}You willown what you have done to Natalee Holloway no matter what …that is Gods” biblical promise.

    37. Natalee Holloway: Deepak & Satish Kalpoe Mislead the Court & Continue with VISA Excuses to Dodge Depositions in LA County, CA Dr Phil Defamation Case | Scared Monkeys on January 31st, 2010 11:23 am

      [...] The Kalpoe brothers were suing for defamation of character. Of course our first thought was, didn’t one have to have character first in order to claim [...]

    38. Craig Crandall on January 12th, 2012 7:33 pm

      SOOOOO! What if we all chipped in to the (who can beat the shit out of a rapest fund ). Whom ever gets to these dumb F##ks first and extracts information from them to close this matter takes all! I would be interested in donating to that worth wild cause. ANY TAKERS!!!!

    Leave a Reply

    Support Scared Monkeys! make a donation.

    • NEWS (breaking news alerts or news tips)
    • Red (comments)
    • Dugga (technical issues)
    • Dana (radio show comments)
    • Klaasend (blog and forum issues)
    E-mail It