WOW, Audience Member Calls Obama a Liar As Obama Says His Obamacare will Not Cover Illegal Aliens



Here is something you don’t see or hear every day … Member in Congress calls Barack Obama a liar when “The One” says that his healthcare system will not cover illegal immigrants.

The reforms I am proposing would not apply to those who are here illegally. You lie!

 UPDATE I: Hot Air claims that the person responsible for calling Barack Obama a liar was South Carolina Representative Joe Wilson.

The culprit was South Carolina rep Joe Wilson, who felt moved to act when The One told what was, in fact, a lie. Although certainly not his biggest of the night: Where this jackass gets off lecturing Americans on civility after his cretinous cronies spent a month demagoging the hell out of every protester in sight is beyond me. You’re Mr. Clean, aren’t you, champ? And bottom-feeders like Harry Reid are your hatchet men. Nice work if you can get it.

UPDATE II: The Gateway Pundit brings up this little tid-bit that shows HR3200 doesn’t require people to establish citizenship or legal residency before applying to exchanges for health insurance.

While Barack Obama insists that the idea that ObamaCare will cover illegal immigrants is a “myth,” the CRS points out that the bill does nothing to prevent it.  Since HR3200 doesn’t require people to establish citizenship or legal residency before applying to exchanges for health insurance, including the public option, taxpayer money will certainly flow to illegal immigrants.


To bad that the comments of “We the People” at Town Hall meetings did not turn the heads of Obama, Biden and Pelosi

One would think though that individuals could have yelled liar at several parts of the Presidents speech tonight. Folks, since when does this administration get anything right when it comes to cost? They could not figure out the cash for clunkers program correctly, do you really think that insuring 47 million, now tonight down to 30 million will cost $900 billion? Go fish.

Next Obama says that you will not lose your health insurance with his Obamacare plan. Wrong. Presently HR3200(149–150), states that an employer can pay an 8% penalty and transfer their employee to the government run public option. If an employer presently pays more than 8% for your insurance coverage, do you honestly think that you will not be switched for bottom line business purposes?

UPDATE I: Before Democrats get all high and mighty and insulted by Obama being called a liar, Democrats pulled this stunt with GWB as well.

Video Flashback: Dems Shout And Boo At Bush During 2005 SOTU [Video]

They also called him a LOSER!

They also called him a LIAR!

UPDATE II: I Think Democrats dost Protest too Much

Since Barack Obama has become President the MSM has acted like there has never been a President ever elected before him and that there has never been down and dirty partisan bickering and politics. The MSM acts as if Democrats have never name called, acted rudely or called Republican Presidents names. Obama, you are not special and you are no different than George W. Bush.

As The Astute Blogger aptly stated, Heckle Obama and you are a racist; Heckle Bush and you are cool with the MSM.


 Hat Tip: Mere Rhetoric

If you liked this post, you may also like these:

  • Didn’t Obama Say Obamacare Would not Cover Illegals? Liberals Seek Healthcare for Illegals
  • Another Campagn Lie … NY Times Reports Obama Campaign Bundlers Have Ties To Lobbying
  • South Carolina Prostitution Ring Busted Involved Illegal Aliens
  • No Obamacare Death Panels Eh? An ObamaCare Surprise, They Begin Jan 1 … Obama added regulation-writing process without telling anybody
  • Democrat Rep Alan Grayson (D-Fla.) Says “If you get Sick, America, the Republican Healthcare plan is this: Die quickly.” and Uses Holocaust Comparison

  • Comments

    39 Responses to “WOW, Audience Member Calls Obama a Liar As Obama Says His Obamacare will Not Cover Illegal Aliens”

    1. rightknight on September 9th, 2009 8:58 pm

      To weasel out of that condemnation by the
      audience member, the way Obowma would
      likely act would be to instantly make all
      the “Illegals” ‘legal’ by decree. I wouldn’t
      put that stupid action past this drunk-with
      -power dude.

    2. fran on September 9th, 2009 9:00 pm

      Oh contrare, he isn’t lying, he’s just “nudging.” He thinks if he says it enough, people will believe him. Unfortunately, many people do and think those still causing a stink about it are full of it.

      You see, coverage for illegal aliens doesn’t need to be in the HC bill. The illegals are already covered under EMTALA of 1989, also known as the “Patient Dumping Act.” Just look it up. Hospitals who receive any type of government money including medicare payments, MUST treat anyone under this law. If they don’t they’re fined, etc, etc, etc……There’s even groups around who advertise on the internet that can help any illegal obtain FREE services.

      It’s called omission……………of the FACTS.

      Question, if they cut $622B from medicare, although it’s said it will run out of money within 8 years without the cut, how are they not going to cut medicare services?

      Oh, and there’s not going to be ‘death panels.’ There will be a group of individuals that can determine that it would be more cost effective if the ‘treatment was NOT available.’ It’s the same pig with lipstick

    3. yoyo muffintop on September 9th, 2009 9:13 pm

      Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.): “Totally disrespectful — [there's] no place for it in that setting or any other and he should apologize immediately.”

      Now line up to crap on Republican John McCain wingnuts. Lol.
      SM: Yea, and there is a reason why this RINO is sitting in the audience and not the President. McCain should grow a pair because the President was lying.

      I think its disrespectful for a President to stand in front of America and lie to them. Deficit neutral. Only cost $900 billion and does not cover illegals, BS!

      Although it might have not been the perfect way to express oneself, I can understand the passion and frustration.

      This President has been lying since he started campaigning and has not stopped. Maybe Pinocchio-Obama needs to start telling the truth on Obamacare.

    4. Scared Monkeys on September 9th, 2009 9:34 pm

      Frank Luntz brought up an interesting nuance. Until tonight, the Democrats and Obama always said that there were 47 million uninsured. Tonight it was 30 million.

      Did he deduct out the illegals? Keep in mind, HR3200 does allow illegals to get healthcare.

    5. ThePlainFacts on September 9th, 2009 9:42 pm

      How exactly does President Obama propose to identify illegal aliens/immigrants? Due to the nature of the crime, illegals don’t exactly walk around with a flashing red sign declaring their status. Rather, many walk around with well-forged documents. Perhaps, Mr. Obama would like to register all of us legal, law-abiding Americans and give us an identifying mark (you know, to show we’re legal)? A mark that enables us to, say, be eligible for government healthcare benefits? Saaay, the government could also use that documentation and mark to counter Identity Theft…what foresight! Oh, and should the economy crash, the government could use those identifiers when it institutes Emergency Martial Law to maintain public order. Disaster relief could require checking that documentation and identifying mark prior to receiving emergency rations for one and one’s family members. “Not in America!”, you say? How else, in the highly technologically advanced world of document forgery, can one definitively distinguish a significant number of illegal aliens/immigrants from legal American citizens? The process, itself, of determining legality demands identification, documentation, and information accessibility. Information accessibility’s Achilles heel is that it depends upon databases (ergo: encryption and subject to potential hacking), thereby rendering that method subject to inevitable failure. Thus sets the stage for introducing a government-enforced mark to identify and “protect” it’s legal citizens. The stage is being set, as we speak with a governmental health care system that can (according to President Obama) differentiate between legal and illegal citizens. So, Mr. President, specifically how will the system identify illegal aliens/immigrants?

    6. KK on September 9th, 2009 10:16 pm

      I don’t know the laws of illegals within health care. What I do know though is what I have been told by Nurses ” Veteran Nurses” * one hospital. in an area of my state that the residential area is overcome by illegals. They demand first treatment in the ER. They Demand treatment and they mean it. 90% have fraudulent identification. But since the area is highly populated within these Illegals – its the Hospital bending over vs lawsuit. The illegals have taken over the public schools within the area so I guess the hospital is the same boat. All goes to show the Masses have a Voice … And WE as US Citizens need to start Banding Together and Fighting for Ourselves Now. Remember WE the People.

    7. rightknight on September 9th, 2009 10:56 pm

      The Ultimate Goal of these clowns is to make
      our Government into an absolute MONOPOLY.
      Health, Production, Law Enforcement, Military,
      Education, Food, Travel, Employment, Insurance,
      Import/Export, Religion, and just about everything
      else one can think of would tier-up to the control
      of the ‘White House’. Who can compete with complete
      and total control? Total control is Totalitarianism is
      its purest sense, no?

      Just one huge family of totally managed Cattle!

    8. Scared Monkeys on September 9th, 2009 11:02 pm

      The problem with the healthcare for illegals is no different than voting and registration.

      Democrats refuse to make it mandatory that people prove who they are.

      OBAMA: “The reforms I’m proposing would not apply to those who are here illegally.” One congressman, South Carolina Republican Joe Wilson, shouted “You lie!” from his seat in the House chamber when Obama made this assertion.

      THE FACTS: The facts back up Obama. The House version of the health care bill explicitly prohibits spending any federal money to help illegal immigrants get health care coverage. Illegal immigrants could buy private health insurance, as many do now, but wouldn’t get tax subsidies to help them. Still, Republicans say there are not sufficient citizenship verification requirements to ensure illegal immigrants are excluded from benefits they are not due.

    9. kitty on September 9th, 2009 11:04 pm

      well said, #5. I’d like my Congressman/Senator to answer what you’ve written…

      maybe it doesn’t matter about having proper documentation ~ because has our President even properly identified himself to be a LEGAL United States Citizen? Hasn’t his Birth documents been sealed? in Hawaii? is that rumor, or true? Is he really a U.S. Citizen?…

      Is our President a LEGAL United States Citizen?

      Is there documentation out there to back it up… or is he a fraud…? Just asking ~ not accusing, just asking ~

      maybe it begins there….and thus it all being allowed ~

      what’s the true agenda here…
      it’s all unfolding ~

    10. yoyo muffintop on September 9th, 2009 11:15 pm

      Rep. Joe Wilson (R-SC):
      “This evening I let my emotions get the best of me when listening to the president’s remarks regarding the coverage of illegal immigrants in the health care bill. While I disagree with the president’s statement, my comments were inappropriate and regrettable. I extend sincere apologies to the president for this lack of civility.”

      Sen. Bob Corker (R-TN)
      “I respect the office of the president and that’s not the kind of thing that to me is appropriate in that kind of setting especially. My sense was that most people there didn’t think it was a good idea that it occurred and I happen to be one of those.”

    11. rightknight on September 9th, 2009 11:21 pm

      I have to admit the absolute joy I felt
      when we watched the combined looks
      of shock and disdain as the three pompous
      people turned to their left with eyes wide
      and mouths open to face the shout. Why
      the audacity of it all was just too hilarious!

    12. Dawg1948 on September 9th, 2009 11:34 pm


      The a$$hole lies (if van Jones can call Republicans such then the President is fair game), if you wish to believe him thats your problem. Although, it may not fit proper etiquette, Mr. Wilson is right. In addition, it is just as wrong for President Obama to lie to the public and quite frankly he has been caught repeatedly while campaigning and as president.

    13. fran on September 10th, 2009 12:29 am

      The facts may back-up Obama in that illegals are not included in the HC bill, HOWEVER, they’re included in FEDERAL LAW. But the problem is, the FEDS don’t pay the bill.

      Please see my post above. There is the ” EMTALA of 1989, also known as the “Patient Dumping Act.””

      It guarantees ANYONE withing the U.S. to receive FREE care. The problem for the individual care givers is it is NOT REIMBURSED by the FEDS. It leaves the bill laying on the individual hospital/ER’s. So they are sparsing words to make it APPEAR as if illegals are NOT getting FREE HC, but they ARE.

      At the end of the day, we’re all paying for this through our health care coverage. Put it into the equation any way you want, it’s still a pig sith lip stick.

    14. super dave on September 10th, 2009 7:07 am

      it sure was funny to watch yoyo”s sister nanfrancisco soil her diaper when this happened. i’m still laughing. yoyo, better get a roll of paper towels and clean up your mess.

    15. super dave on September 10th, 2009 7:09 am

      watching the continous eye blinking from beavis biden is a sure sign that all this democratic
      foriegn language is a complete lie.
      obama swallowed his own purple lips after being called out. funny!

    16. Carpe on September 10th, 2009 7:26 am

      Here is a great idea… to people who don’t have
      a prayer of affording insurance… let’s require
      them legally to be fined up to 3.8k if they don’t
      step up to the plate and pay for health ins.
      with money THEY DON’T HAVE, NEVER HAD, AND PROBABLY WILL NEVER GET. What a great plan for
      someone who would love to have the debt load
      of a major operation… but actually does not
      want to go through the pesky ordeal of having
      their malfunctioning body part physically removed!


      It’s the LAW. Don’t get yourself all WEE-WEED up over it. IN-FRIGGIN-SANITY! Look it up.

    17. super dave on September 10th, 2009 7:47 am

      actually calling oblankma a liar is not as bad as nanfrancisco calling Americans standing up for their rights terrorists. if the name fits, wear it barry.

    18. Rust Bridges on September 10th, 2009 8:00 am

      It was rude, plain and simple. All it did was make the Repubs look bad and help Obama/Dems cause. It was exciting though.

      My wife is uninsured and her hours cut back at work as well as mine. I like what Obama has said, if he can back it that is good for me and my family so I’m with him on this.

      I’m done worrying about politics, where was the Repubs health care proposal they were waving around last night eight years ago?

      I heard that there is something about give me your tired, sick and downtrodden etched on the Statue of Liberty, so until someone takes a cutting torch to that we are bound to take care immigrants.

    19. Scott on September 10th, 2009 8:07 am

      Did the Dems apologize to Bush for booing him during the State of the Union? I don’t think so….

      More of the same liberal hypocrisy that exists within that party and the digusting people like yoyo….

    20. Scott on September 10th, 2009 8:36 am

      First of all, the government under the constitution (you know the document that defines our individual freedoms) can NOT REQUIRE you to have health insurance NOR can they mandate anything on you but to pay your taxes…PERIOD.

      He’s stepping all over the Constitution…that’s what Marxists do..

    21. Scott on September 10th, 2009 8:38 am

      Rusty…you are a fool….I’ve got some waterfront property for you in Arizona if you believe that….

      He has said the same exact things he’s been saying for months and nobody buys it….

      Did he explain how he is going to actually pay for it in the world called REALITY? NOPE….

      Keep drinking the kool-aide idiot!

    22. Scott on September 10th, 2009 8:39 am

      BTW Dusty Britches — it didn’t help the dems cause at all…it was an outburst plain and simple…its amazing how the Obama kool-aide drinkers make a mountain out of a mole hole…LOL!

    23. ANewGirl on September 10th, 2009 9:36 am


      There are not sufficient citizenship verification requirements to ensure illegal immigrants are excluded from benefits they are not due.
      There you go!

      FACT: I witnessed this incident in Mass Hospital this year. An ILLEGAL ALIEN, sat in an Emergency Room in a Beverly, MA hospital waiting to get his infected tooth which was causing him severe head pain attended to by a Physician. Of course, it got to this state since Dental Care is not something illegals pay any attention to. Even through the complete triage, to which I was present–when all information was taken down and entered into a computer—(including lack of a SSN, patient just shook head and played dumb!) not ONCE was the man asked for any ID to prove he was who he said he was. Of course, upon hearing he did not have any health insurance (not even Mass Health) not an eyelashed was batted. Business as usual.

      So—who paid for this emergency visit?? You and I, that’s who. Now, tell me again under the new plan—how is any of this going to change? Oh, that’s right—this illegal alien is going to “contribute” to a plan from which he can pick afforable health care, right? BS!!!!!!!

      It was worth the look alone on Pelosi’s face in this a.m’s newsclips when Wilson shouted that out. Also noted in the news how it was the first time in a Congressional Address that a President themself ever used the term “Lies”.
      So, what next????

    24. tuyvnsurvivor on September 10th, 2009 11:33 am

      The slight of height from which democrats, liberals and Chicago Obama suck the life out of America is new…untried from the inside and not as notable a try by Hitler and Japan combined. For my view, Republican (correct spelling)members of congress insult me with their cowardice…McCain leading the ineptness.

      But then I was proud of Wilson. Ooops…he apologized right away. If only I could have been a representitive I am certain an Obama could not deliver such antagonizing, inflamitory, conflictual, lying, suggest-a-wordy speech until I was horizonally removed. That is what I want of my Senator and representitives. And no apology!

    25. tuyvnsurvivor on September 10th, 2009 11:56 am

      A failure of Republican members of congress is they allow mainstreem media (MSM) to follow and report for liberals and the march to sociolisum. Individual Rebuplican members, if brave; together, if weaklings — must pounce on moments, which would scream to MSM, ‘you must report this’!

      It is what ‘actout liberals’ did to get us here. If the foe is with horse and sharp point, foot travel is risky for a dull boy. This is the greatest battle for this country in its history. The lack of urgency by Republican members of congress is of a loser nature.

    26. rightknight on September 10th, 2009 12:02 pm

      Dr. Obowma, DDS: I’ve found a small cavity.
      Patient: Oh my, what do you suggest, a filling?
      Dr. Obowma: No, it’s a dangerous cavity and immediate
      surgery is required.
      Patient: Surgery?
      Dr. Obowma: Absolutely urgent. I will remove all your
      natural teeth, excise the underlying gums and replace the
      bone structure of the jaw with my new paper mache material.
      On that base will be a complete set of brand new wooden
      teeth. Any failures in the future will be covered by your
      own nest egg.
      Patient: I trust your word, Doctor, you are the expert!

    27. Rust Bridges on September 10th, 2009 12:36 pm

      #21, he has a plan and has ideas on how to get it done. is it perfect? No, even he said so. Thats why he addressed congress to get it done.

      Where is your guy with a better idea?

      Nice having an intelligent conversation with you.

    28. super dave on September 10th, 2009 12:45 pm

      the beast is at your door. obama, one world currency, united nations, democrats, liberals, healthcare reform. put the newspaper and the bible side by side, they match !!

    29. tuyvnsurvivor on September 10th, 2009 12:55 pm

      Republican congress members: next time a wordy conflictual address is anticipated, let it be known to media and sociolist President “we give the Pres 2 minutes from the opening, to wage assualt and political diatribe, after that, if he has not moved on to international affairs or away from America blame — we engauge and respond. It is then enteraction time! 120 seconds of liberal, unanswered, hate. Only.”

    30. kitty on September 10th, 2009 8:49 pm

      Congressman Joe Wilson was honest, spoke truth and was full up in his belly of the B.S. lies so he blurted out, what about all of us are fed up with ~ the LIES…

      Congressman Wilson deserves a handshake ~ and a pat on the back… oh, all he needs to say is: ” I behaved stupidly” , bring out the Sam Adams Beer and hey, I’ll salute this guy ~ bout time a Congressman had the kahoonas to speak truth… decorum or not ~ he’s my hero~!

      He aught to run for President, have Sgt. Crowley for his running mate ~ now, there ya go ~ Octoberfest has begun~!

    31. kitty on September 10th, 2009 8:49 pm

      Bring on another beer summitt!

    32. hat on September 14th, 2009 9:45 pm

      The Senator of South Carolina needs to be replaced with someone with a brain.

      The Governor of South Carolina needs to be replaced with someone with a brain.

      These zombie like persons should not hold a position to even lead the people or address our President as their present performance and simple-minded utterance shows.

    33. Didn’t Obama Say Obamacare Would not Cover Illegals? Liberals Seek Healthcare for Illegals | Scared Monkeys on September 29th, 2009 10:15 am


    34. Democrat Rep Alan Grayson (D-Fla.) Says “If you get Sick, America, the Republican Healthcare plan is this: Die quickly.” and Uses Holocaust Comparison | Scared Monkeys on September 30th, 2009 11:07 pm

      [...] floor of the House of Representatives? Or is that only reserved for Republicans when they call out “you lie” to the President when, basically the President was lying. Once again, today Democrats voted down a [...]

    35. Barack Obama Thumbs his Nose at Separation of Powers and Insults the SCOTUS … Low Rent and No Class | Scared Monkeys on January 28th, 2010 12:23 am

      [...] and this President and his fellow Democrat minions go upset when  Rep. Joe Wilson R-(SC) said, “You Lie”.  Barack Obama lectured the Congress and America during his State of the Union Speech on civility [...]

    36. Democrat Congressman Overheard Muttering “F*ck The President” During House Dem Caucus on Obama’s Tax-Cut Deal | Scared Monkeys on December 10th, 2010 9:07 am

      [...] “You Lie” seems in retrospect so much more mild than what is coming from the mouths of Democrats [...]

    37. No Obamacare Death Panels Eh? An ObamaCare Surprise, They Begin Jan 1 … Obama added regulation-writing process without telling anybody | Scared Monkeys on December 26th, 2010 12:29 pm

      [...] to Logan’s Run … Barack Obama Healthcare Carosel Edition, aka Obama Healthcare You Lie, [...]

    38. Its Just a Coincidence That Barack Obama Scheduled Joint Session of Congress Speech on Same Date & Time as GOP Debate at Reagan Library … LIARS!!! | Scared Monkeys on August 31st, 2011 11:38 pm

      [...] say, it was just a coincidence. To borrow a phrase from was South Carolina Rep Joe Wilson …  YOU LIE!!! “It is coincidental,” said spokesman Jay Carney at today’s press briefing. “There are a lot [...]

    39. Another Campagn Lie … NY Times Reports Obama Campaign Bundlers Have Ties To Lobbying | Scared Monkeys on October 28th, 2011 8:35 am

      [...] SC Representative would say, “You Lie!” Also, as Weasel Zippers reminds us, how bad and blatant a situation must this be if the New York [...]

    Leave a Reply

    Support Scared Monkeys! make a donation.

    • NEWS (breaking news alerts or news tips)
    • Red (comments)
    • Dugga (technical issues)
    • Dana (radio show comments)
    • Klaasend (blog and forum issues)
    E-mail It