Caylee Anthony Missing: Why did the Grand Mother, Cindy Anthony, Change her story that”‘smelled like dead body” in 911 call


The case of missing 2 year old Caylee Anthony has gone from the strange to the bizarre. Why did Caylee Marie’s grandmother change the story? How did the story change from the 911 call where she stated, it smells like there’s been a dead body in the damn car to  it was just pizza in the trunk.

“I have someone here who I need be arrested and a possible missing child,” she told a 911 dispatcher. “A 3-year-old that has been missing for a month.”

Anthony placed the call around 8:45 p.m., and answered the dispatcher’s questions impatiently. But less than an hour later, she was on the phone with dispatchers again – this time screaming and crying. She’d discovered her granddaughter had allegedly been kidnapped by the baby sitter.

Her daughter, Casey Anthony, had been missing for a month and the car she was driving – a white 1998 Pontiac Firebird – had been towed. Cindy Anthony found her daughter and the car, but not the child.

Her daughter, Casey Anthony, had been missing for a month and the car she was driving – a white 1998 Pontiac Firebird – had been towed. Cindy Anthony found her daughter and the car, but not the child.

“There is something wrong…I found my daughter’s car today, it smells like there’s been a dead body in the damn car,” Cindy Anthony yelled into the receiver.

When Casey Anthony, the missing girl’s mother, was put on the phone, she remained calm.

“My daughter’s been missing for the last 31 days,” Casey Anthony said.

When a dispatcher asked why she hadn’t come to the police earlier, she claimed that she had done her own searching. (Olando Sentinel)

If you liked this post, you may also like these:

  • Scared Monkeys Radio Daily Commentary – Monday, July 28, 2008 – There’s More Going On In The Caylee Marie Anthony Case Than What We Know
  • Caylee Anthony Missing: Cindy Anthony on The Today Show (9/2/08)
  • Caylee Marie Anthony Still Missing as Cindy Anthony, Grandmother Makes Ridiculous Dispute of Decomposition Scent from Mothers Trunk was Pizza
  • Missing: Cindy Anthony Says … “I believe we’re going to find Caylee” Anthony
  • Caylee Anthony Missing: The Bizarre Casey Anthony’s Phone Calls from Jail with her Mom Cindy Anthony

  • Comments

    61 Responses to “Caylee Anthony Missing: Why did the Grand Mother, Cindy Anthony, Change her story that”‘smelled like dead body” in 911 call”

    1. da_wench on July 25th, 2008 10:36 am

      Casey has been a liar all of her life and has never had to face the consequences, thanks to her mother. I truely believe that Caylee’s death was accidental. I believe Casey was neglectful for leaving her in a hot car and is now trying to lie her way out of it like she’s done all her life. Fortunately, the police aren’t as stupid as her mother. I can’t believe that crazy lady used the rotten pizza story after she herself had already claimed the car smelled like a dead body. What a nut job!

      Bless you, Caylee. May you rest in peace.

    2. misskatie on July 25th, 2008 12:03 pm


      amen to that loud and clear..I agree

    3. Susy Q on July 25th, 2008 12:10 pm

      that grandmother makes me furious I just want to slap her and her lying daughter! ! ! what losers ! ! poor little Caylee….

    4. misskatie on July 25th, 2008 1:02 pm

      Susy Q

      with family like that the poor lil girl never had a chance.. mother seemed to enable and make excuses for her daughter… the mother thinks as long as they cant find the body to prove the little girl dead… is to her advantage…
      I think not!!

    5. da_wench on July 25th, 2008 1:20 pm

      Did Casey Anthony follow the Natalee Holloway case and think she could get away with telling ridiculous lies to law enforcement? First of all, this is NOT Aruba. Second, her daddy isn’t a wannabe judge giving her advice on how to beat the system.

    6. Maggie on July 25th, 2008 2:38 pm

      On the tape you hear the daughter tell the 911 operator the name of the nanny that she claimed took her, that she left Caylee with.. She even spells the name of the nanny, said she talked to her recently and spoke with Caylee also. The mother tells the 911 operator, the phone number has now been disconnected. On Nancy Grace’s show yesterday, they said police had located the woman with that name and the woman stated she didn’t even know Caylee’s mom.

      On Dana’s show a few nights ago a D.A. Mark Werksmen made a comment , similar to, the grandmother appearing on tv over and over asking everyone to help find her granddaughter and why should we be looking, when her daughter has the answers, she was last with her and not talking now, go talk to her daughter. Today, the grandfather is asking everyone, yet his daughter still sits in jail silent and won’t help the cops find Caylee and has lied to them.

      If my 2 year old daughter was missing, the last thing I would be worried about is hiring a defense attorney.

    7. Bystander on July 25th, 2008 3:27 pm

      How many folks really believe the defense attorney when he was asked if he believes (what ever)Casey Anthony has told him? He said “absolutely.” To me he was not very convincing and it is such a shame that a attorney would agree to defend a person who is unwilling to support the police and locate their own missing child. Also, I think the grandmother knows more than what she is telling and her first response were more truthful due to her initial reaction. Now she seems less truthful as time goes on.

      And what’s with the mother not seeming concern about Casey and her car missing for a month as well. Several things obviously do not add up.
      Crazy family.

    8. Just Bearly on July 25th, 2008 3:29 pm

      The car story smells really fishy to me….

      It was also one of my first thoughts that she(the Mother) is on drugs based on her demeanor and appearance. If Grandma is covering for the daughter, she is an accomplice to the crime and should be arrested too.

    9. Carpe on July 25th, 2008 4:01 pm

      Casey even lied to cops and said she worked
      at Universal Studios. I mean, how psychotic
      is that? A person has the cops all over them,
      and they lie about something so easily checked
      out about where they work? Universal says NO.

      She lied about the nanny’s residence. It has
      been sitting vacant for 5 months.

      Allegedly, at certain points throughout her police
      interrogation, she is laughing.

      This bizzer is nuts!!!

    10. Carpe on July 25th, 2008 6:13 pm
    11. May on July 25th, 2008 11:47 pm

      All she wants to do is talk to Tony…Why won’t anyone listen. why do they not believe her when she says she wants to find her daughter……………Seriously if my little girl was missing, then everyone else can go the he….you get my point. I hope she breaks soon, and gives authorities the help they need to try and save this baby………. and if it is to late, I love you Caylee RIP you deserved better!!!

    12. Too strange on July 26th, 2008 12:26 am

      This conversation is so strange. The mother is all about herself. It’s mind blowing.

    13. Carpe on July 26th, 2008 1:34 am

      okay… now we have some conflicting info.

      Fox 35 Orlando

      In reference to reports of a concrete slab recently being poured in the family’s backyard, Padilla says the information is incorrect. “There’s no slab back there unless we’re blind bats,” he said.

      He did confirm that there were square pavers down on the ground but no concrete was poured. “Let’s say Caylee had been back there. The dogs would have alerted us, ” Padilla said.

      The Orange County Sheriff’s Office says they are sure nothing is in the backyard and they have no plans on going back.

      FOX NEWS CHANNEL Fri. night

      Phil Keating indicates towards the
      end of his live shot, that they had cadaver
      dog hits on the car and backyard.

    14. Susan on July 26th, 2008 5:25 am

      Arrest Cynthia Anthony now!! She is guilty of murder, obstruction of justice, lying to law enforcement officials, etc.

      I was shocked to hear the taped jailhouse telephone conversation between Casey, her mom, brother, and a friend of the family last night. Like mother, like daughter…

      God bless little Caylee :-)

    15. txchic on July 26th, 2008 9:09 am

      the whole thing stinks.

      how can casey sit calmly in a car next to her mother while her mom is telling police that she needs to bring her daughter in for stealing an auto & $$$?

      then cynthia tells the daughter that she’ll not give her another day as she’s already given her a month to find the child?

      it’s obvious that casey has some sort of mental health issues. she just doesn’t seem to “get it”. the mom/daughter relationship is strange at best.

    16. Maggie on July 26th, 2008 9:18 pm

      Wanted to share this 2 minute YouTube video I received this week, it can bring a tear to your eye.. It’s about 2 minutes long. Sad when animals are more humane then some humans.. I loved this and it’s a true story. Poor Caylee, who has been looking out for Caylee’s well being? Mother worried about her boyfriend’s telephone number and complaining in jail all they want to talk about is Caylee. I don’t see a good outcome to this story..

      Christian the Lion..

      A little more on the subject if you want to read it.

    17. brie. on July 27th, 2008 12:27 am

      I think Casey killed and buried Caylee…and I don’t believe there was any kidnapping involved…I don’t know what Cyndia’s involvement is but first she calls and wants Casey arrested for stealing the car and the credit card and reports Caylee missing rather calmly…then she calls back and reports again that Caylee is missing and is hysterical….

    18. Carpe on July 27th, 2008 3:16 am

      Caylee Anthony Case – the grandfather talks

      Geraldo / FOX July 26th 2008

      Caylee Anthony Case – review

      Geraldo / FOX July 26th 2008

    19. Jean on July 27th, 2008 6:06 am

      Turns out the grandfather, George Anthony, was a detective on the police force in the town in Pennsylvania they moved from when Casey was 3.

      Yes, he could be telling Casey how to beat the rap.

    20. Maggie on July 27th, 2008 4:48 pm

      I was thinking maybe the boyfriend had something to do with Caylee being gone.. The mother keeps wanting his phone number.. Wonder why if he’s her bf, she don’t already have his number? Maybe the mother did something with Caylee, to get back at her grandmother. Maybe even sell her don’t know, but something really stinks..

      Last night Geraldo said the mother said she would talk to the FBI..but not the police. She don’t trust them. What can the police do to her if she did nothing wrong? Good grief what an airhead , her daughter is missing over 31 days now and she’s not talking, and making comments all they keep asking questions about is Caylee. and she wonders why she is in jail??? 99 percent of the the time it’s always the last known person with the victim and not a stranger. She acts like it’s nothing for a 2 year old to be missing for over a month.

    21. MissKatie on July 27th, 2008 5:09 pm

      let me tell you all something (FELLOW MONKEY’S)
      if that was my grandaughter lost and my daughter responsible.. I would disown her for killing one of my grandbabies… thats how I see it (@@)

      they are pampering her (CAYLEES PITIFUL MOM)and enabling her behaviour..
      the story she is tellin that caylees out there !!!and that police wont listen TO HER is… full of crap!!! that the lawyer and family have created…THE LAWYER REMINDS ME OF CREW PETERSONS DUMB LAWYER

      the mother’s major concern is talking to her boyfriend!!theres something wrong with that picture…
      the conversations between mother and daughter are hella weird tooo….

      maybe the lil girl was a nuisance to the mom and boyfriend and they wanted her outta the way.. hell anythings possible with these nuts!!!I pray for caylee to be found safe and if not may the lil angel rest in peace…

    22. May on July 27th, 2008 5:09 pm

      Maggie I wondered the same thing…Why doesn’t she know “Tony’s” phone number? Even in this cell phone world I know the phone numbers of those closest to me. Why does Casey blow off her friend and brother(I omit the grandma because I feel she knows something) when they ask about her daughter. Why does she refuse to tell them anything? Why, because they are outside the loop, that’s why, and she is not about to bring the inside.

    23. Donna on July 27th, 2008 5:20 pm

      This question is for Cindy Anthony:
      If you feel law enforcement is not handling this case the way that you believe they should, have you contacted Texas EquuSearch, The Polly Klaas Foundation, and/or The Jessica Lundsford Foundation?
      It is apparent that Casey knows precisely where Caylee is and her fate will be sealed when that location is found!!!! I for one, can’t wait until the truth finally prevails.

    24. Carpe on July 28th, 2008 1:40 pm


      Cindy Anthony speaks to Shep at FOX NEWS.


    25. Carpe on July 28th, 2008 2:43 pm

      Zenaida Fernandez-Gonzalez
      composite sketch finally made
      by Casey.

    26. Maggie on July 28th, 2008 4:24 pm

      ty for the youtube

      very odd about this babysitter.. They have been reporting the address the mother Casey, gave for the babysitter, cops checked it out and noone has lived there for 5 months and another night on another show..they said cops talked to this woman and she said she had never met Caylee’s mom.

    27. Ray on July 28th, 2008 10:20 pm

      It is real simple people,the mother would be right at home in ARUBA with the rest of those lairs. She thinks she can lie her way out of this,I DONT THINK SO.

    28. Rollo on July 29th, 2008 12:02 am

      I have seen every interview/phone call from jail, etc… my conclusion is the police need to concentrate on WHERE Casey buried Caylee’s body.
      I think that is probably what they are doing now.
      The shovel, the cadaver dog, the dirt, Casey ditched the car, she tells a former boyfriend she is available now,… the sooner authorities locate the body, the better before it decomposes much more. Casey’s main concern is getting out of jail, because she is spoiled and had few limits put on her growing up. I sense she has dominance over her mother, and probably has a weak relationship with her father. I lived in a rural community where two teenage boys executed two FBI informants in a cattle-rustling ring. They were easily convicted because there were obvious bodies found, and the rifles were found buried in the boy’s back yard. But…..the mother of the boys stood by them all the way, “no way my boys could do that” blah blah..and the father of the boys kind of remained silent, in the background… has similarities. I think Caylee’s death was an accident from neglect. I think Casey went to another city to meet up with some guy, her boyfriend maybe, or to spy on him for some reason, and Caylee made it difficult to do these activities with this Tony person. She probably coerced Caylee into taking a “nap” in the trunk of her car. Why the trunk? Because a 3 year old can unlock doors and get out of a car, but she would be “safe”, in Casey’s mind, in the trunk. She probably got zoned out on dope or something, with a guy, and woke up 12 hours later and discovered her daughter dead in the hot trunk when she realized how much time had gone by.
      She is trying to distract investigators and buy some time, it seems, with all the outrageous lies and behavior. After all, her lies always worked before, did’nt they, Cindy? George? Hello?
      I am on YOUR side, little Caylee.

    29. Shiloh on July 29th, 2008 12:21 pm

      The family of Casey Anthony is in court asking to have all tapes not released to public as they could be used against Casey in a future trial.
      humm. Does that mean that the family is holding back evidence?
      Why are they so concerned with the tapes. No other prisoner has that right in FL.
      They released the Hogan tapes.
      If Cindy Anthony does not want incriminating evidence about her then why does she lie in every interview?
      She has lied about when she found out Caylee was missing. She lied about hearing the phone call from the babysitter(the phone was lost prior to the call). She lied about the smell; dead body/pizza.
      She lied about Casey talking to police on the 911 call.
      She was more interested in getting her computer back then meeting with the FBI.
      When are the Anthony’s going to submit to a polygraph??

    30. Scared Monkeys Radio Daily Commentary - Monday, July 28, 2008 - There’s More Going On In The Caylee Marie Anthony Case Than What We Know | Scared Monkeys on July 29th, 2008 10:00 pm

      [...] Caylee Anthony Missing: Why did the Grand Mother, Cindy Anthony, Change her story that”’smelled … [...]

    31. Jenny on July 31st, 2008 10:12 am

      Pay less attention to Cindy’s words now. This poor woman is trying to reassure her lying daughter that she has faith in her so she might come clean. If Cindy says to the media that she’s lost faith in Casey, Casey definitely won’t come clean. None of us will know for sure what Cindy really thinks until after Caylee is found. Cindy knows her daughter is trash, but she’ CAN’T say so now, she really can’t.

      I think Caylee possibly got brought along for a drug deal and was hidden in the trunk. I think cars may have been switched and Casey wouldn’t have wanted to speak up and say she’d brought her kid along… I fear Caylee died prior to the car being impounded.

    32. Waco,TX (What?!?) on August 1st, 2008 1:05 am

      How pathetic! Why is the grandmother asking the public for assistance that her own daughter want even give her. I love my children and would die for them, but if my grand-daughter was missing and my daughter continually lied about her where abouts….I would literally grab her by her heels, hold her upside down and shake the truth out of her. She continues to lie, because her mother is giving her the reassurance that its ok to lie, because no matter what I’ll be there. There is nothing wrong with standing in support of your child, but not in support of their behavior. This grand-mother has it all wrong and is asking questions to the wrong people and obviously looking in the wrong direction. Poor Caylee she certainly needed the public’s help, but it was long before she came up missing. This family is SICK and the relationship is unhealthy. Judging by the recordings who do you think is the mother in this situation? Casey/Cindi?

    33. kendra on August 1st, 2008 11:06 pm

      I don’t think Cindy is guilty of anything except hoping upon hope that Casey’s unlikely and unbelievable stories have some truth in them. I think every day she really knows more and more that Casey is responsible for the probable death of Caylee, but until they actually find Caylee, she wants to believe that Caylee is alive. If she admits to herself now that Casey is most likely a murderer, then she gives up all hope that the granddaughter she loves so much is gone.

      She wants to believe it’s pizza and she wants us to believe it’s pizza and that Caylee is happy and alive. If she admits to herself and to us and the media that it’s truly human decomposition, she will crack.

      Lee’s phone calls to Casey are the most telling. He has started to hate her– it’s so obvious. Their phone calls on 7/30 and 7/31 prove this to me. She never brings up Caylee– it’s all “hi, I miss you, how you doin’?” He answers her with as much kindness as he can muster and his answers are terse. He tries to turn the conversation to Caylee, and she just follows along realizing she has to, but she absolutely has no interest in doing so. He asks her about the letter he asked her to write 5 to 6 days ago, and she STILL hasn’t gotten to it– as if her jail days are filled with more important activities!

      My heart completely goes out to Lee, Cindy, and George. If the investigators find Caylee dead, Cindy will have a breakdown. And, she will not show as much support towards Casey as she’s showing now. Her support is based on keeping her hope alive and that’s it. George and Lee have almost accepted the worst. Cindy can’t face it yet.

    34. kendra on August 2nd, 2008 10:13 am

      Just wanted to make another comment. If (and it appears likely) Caylee is dead, I do NOT think the death was accidental. If Caylee’s death was accidental as some here pondered, than Casey would be distraught. She might not appear distraught NOW, since she’s trying to get released and appear innocent, but she would have, most likely, appeared distraught in some of those photos that have surfaced of her partying at those clubs.

      The only way she could be happy, is if Caylee’s death occurred because she WANTED it to occur. People become happy when they get what they desire or when their attempts at fulfilling a desire occur. If the death was accidental we would see her looking worse for wear in those photos– not glowing and happy. Also, if it was accidental, she most likely would have admitted it (crying and emotional) to the police since she’d be suffering so much. None of these traits appear.

      There is no way any mother whose child dies accidentally could go out partying without an apparent care in the world. Only a criminal who doesn’t care her child is gone could do so.

    35. er margie on August 3rd, 2008 8:28 pm

      When I first started reading about this case,I thought how stupid can this family be? I was mistaken,Casey is not stupid, she is one very slick cookie.Just because she tells lies, is unemotional,self centered and controlling does not make someone a killer. Oh, I truely believe she caused Caylee’s death ,but so far with all the facts we have,no one can say 100% she did it.She has committed the perfect crime, so far. I do believe that eventually the truth shall prevail.No help from Casey though. Like I said one smart cookie. She has told so many lies,so often that she truely believes the story she is telling. Maybe she thinks the more she tells everyone we’ll start to believe it to. Cindy is no shrinking violet either.When she blurted out “the car smells like a dead body was in it”,that was said in the heat of the moment,with all the emotion and fear that anyone would have said it.Of course she had to change her story to the pizza theory, other wise she would basically be admitting that Casey killed Caylee.She also changed her story from” I want my daughter arrested for stealing money and the car” to I told them anything to get them to come to the house. That inital phone call she was very calm and she added almost as an after thought her grandaughter was missing. I must admit Lee Anthony was very good at trying to explain away all the comments his mother and sister made,but I didn’t buy it.He said his mother was in contact every day with Casey,sometimes twice a day,and that when his mother made the statement “I have given you a month” what she really meant was, I have talked to you everyday for a month and I have waited everyday for a month to talk to Caylee and I’m not waiting another day.I really liked when he explained why Casey wanted her boyfriends number. He said that Casey had been going through a very rough time for the last month and her boyfriend was close to her the whole time,so it is natural that she would want to talk to the one person that she has been so close to. What a crock! I believe from all I’ve read the boyfriend did’nt even know the child was missing,oops I mean kidnapped,real close huh. A small consolation, Caylee is at peace and Casey will have her days of reckoning, here on earth and when she meets her maker.

    36. Fal29 on August 8th, 2008 2:44 pm

      What you do in this world you get back. The whole family is WACKED!!! They will all pay even when they DIE they will still be punished by satan. That was a innocent baby she was only 2 still innocent she is way better off than with that whole nutty evil family. Who stays calm on the phone when there child is missing HELLO!!! could it be the person who murdered her I believe so. If it was an accident or not she is the mother is still to blame careless I hope they at least find her body and give her a proper burrial it just so sad to even watch my heart is brokeen and I don’t even know the little angel my prayers are with you Caylee!!!

    37. robyn king on August 9th, 2008 6:27 am

      i think caseys mom is just in denial.she wants so much to see her grandchild again.she is afraid if she alienates her crazy daughter casey she never will and cannot accept the fact that most likely casey murdered caylee cause she was sick and tired of her cramping her partying life and was jealous that her family loves caylee more than they ever loved her.i do believe casey is bi-polar and schizo because of her unending lies.i have a niece who is like this ,she lies so much she never even stops to make anything new up.everything out of her mouth is just a continuing lie.most likely into drugs my niece loved vicodin but if she didnt have that then beer was good.i have also seen the effects of meth on peoples minds and she could have been under the influence of meth. i do not think caylees death was a accident i think it was pre-mediateted murder.just like poor trenton duckett who was murdered by his own mom 2 years ago before she committed suicide.she killed her son to spite and hurt her ex-husband the boys father.i think there is a lot wrong with this family but i think they loved this child and would never hurt her.but casey only loves herself!!!casey hates her family and is a user and a loser.i know people like her,caylee was her meal ticket people tolerated her because of the child other than that none of them would have lifted a finger for casey cause they were sick and tired of her free loading,partying lazy a ss!!i hope they find caylees body today so she can have a proper burial and i hope her mom is executed the selfish,sickening,lying winch!

    38. PsychoFinder007 on August 9th, 2008 10:55 pm

      Iv’e been following the story from beginning to up to date. I have professional experience in Psychopathy and Sociopathy. It appears from all evidence thus far, behaviour on the part of Casey Anthony is nothing short of being a Sociopath. This person has no capability to have empathy. She is a Pathological Liar, and believes her own lies. She can never be rehabilitated, not even if she spend the rest of her days in confinment with extensive therapy. This young woman needs to be behind bars. She is quite dangerous, and could be harmful to others.
      On a more personal emotional level, I hope and pray that FBI and other Investigators find the missing child – Caylee alive and well, but realistically, Casey is a Psychopath/Sociopath, they will probably not find Caylee alive. This is a hard pill for us all to swallow, and hard for normal people to get their minds around a Psychopath. These individuals live in their own reality apart from true reality. It’s very disturbing, and there are many of them just like Casey out there walking free, so I am very glad that She is behind bars, and hope that that is where she will remain the rest of her miserable life.

    39. smarie on August 11th, 2008 7:00 pm


    40. Sylvia on August 12th, 2008 8:23 am

      Let’s be real. None of us (public) knows what is going on behind the scenes of this terrible ordeal. I’m sure neighbors are being questioned at length, along with any “friend” of Casey’s – and probably Cindy & George’s friends and associates. In my opinion, the family has had a long history of arguments/battles, etc. leading to the one that “broke the camels back” – on Father’s Day. According to one neighbor, it was reported that there was loud arguing at the house that day. I believe Caylee is dead. Casey is most likey responsible for the death of Caylee and sadly, at this time, it looks like it can not be proven. Give it time – they will prove it! And, when they do prove it, I think they will find at least one other person who helped Casey (after the fact) to dispose of her little body. Could be a parent, could be a friend (boyfriend or ex-boy friend).

    41. Cher on The Beach on August 13th, 2008 2:04 am

      Why do they not do a lie detector test on Casey?
      And Maybe the Grandmother too? IF they want the child back,they would do whatever it took…The whole case seem wierd. If they think someone crossed state lines..get the FBI. Maybe they can
      get this case moving as the police in Orlando or Sheriffs seem like they need help.

    42. What if on August 15th, 2008 2:04 pm

      Suppose Caylee was being molested in the Anthony home. And she couldn’t just leave with the baby, because she was being blackmailed for something serious she had done. And Casey stole all that money to give to the people to care for her and then made up a nanny story.

    43. What if on August 15th, 2008 2:17 pm

      I cracked the case!

    44. betty on August 18th, 2008 10:05 am

      I truly believe that caylee died in the trunk of that car. Casey didn’t have a babysitter and put her in the trunk and told het to take a little nap and mommy will be back and then went into the bar to party and forgot about her and then it was to late when she checked on her. She then left her in the trunk for a few days to figure out what to do and poor caylee started to decompose in the swealtering heat in that trunk. What a truly sad thing thing. Rest in peace caylee.

    45. Tammie on August 19th, 2008 11:05 pm

      I think Casey is guilty, but I don’t think she did this to get rid of the burden of Caylee, because her mom would have more than likely have taken care of her, which tells me that she didn’t need any babysitter!

    46. Mary Delorme on August 20th, 2008 3:02 am

      I think Caylee drowned in the pool. Maybe Casey
      was on the phone and forgot that she had left the ladder up and did not lock the gate. She is guilty
      of neglect and impeding the police and hiding the body.This mother needs to be locked up for a few
      years for what she has done, how much has she cost
      law enforcement and the state because of all her
      lies.This child deserves a decent burial and the only one that can ensure that is that miserable mother.

    47. terry on August 25th, 2008 6:48 am

      i think that caylee is dead and casey is never never going to tell. i think she drowned while she was in the house sleeping or either on the phone. i think she is a bi polar bitch and my ex daughter in law had the same personality as her and she never bonded with her son either, she was also more worried about partyiong and drugs than her son.

    48. LYNDA on August 25th, 2008 5:41 pm


    49. Ashley on August 30th, 2008 5:51 pm

      Makes me wonder if the Grandparents did it. Every time someone asks Cindy about her daughters involvement with Caylee’s disappearance she clams up gets edgy and then says something like “let’s focus on finding Caylee”. Maybe the closer they get to Casey- the closer they get to her? Grant it, Casey’s stories are full of lies, but Cindy’s are too. There’s no evidence on Casey and her GPs are the last to see her alive. There are claims that Cindy had more of a bond with Caylee, so maybe if Casey was going to leave with Caylee it would certainly give Cindy a motive. What’s Casey’s motive? It might be a distraction.
      This is absolutly crazy! This is the only other theory I can think of.

    50. Lynne on August 31st, 2008 2:54 pm

      Cindy Anthony is old, desperate, in utter denile and now clearly has lost her freaking mind.
      She went from, “it smells like a dead body in the damn car” to “its a rotting pizza” to, “there was no odor at all, NO ODOR!” She needs to be sent to the looney bin..If she gets on the stand she’ll be arrested for purjury.

    51. Courtney on August 31st, 2008 3:16 pm

      All I have to say about Cindy Anthony is….The apple doesnt fall far from the tree.

    52. Bre'anna on December 5th, 2008 9:21 am

      alright listen bitchez! Now we alreadi kno dat her mom killed caylee because she likes her grandparents better i guess..and caylee’s mom is just jelous and can’t nobodi help dat..But she’s wrong 4 killing her daughter regardless that was a foul move..i mean i personally would not kill my daughter because shee likes 2 spend time wit her grandparents..i mean i wud b happy and plus that gives you time 2 do thingz on ur spare timeu kno? And yea i agree with cher they shud get a lie detector test on casey’s ass! i mean why would she do that to her gergous little girl….i mean just by looking at her she’s so innocent looking and so cute she shud be happy and proud that she made a gergous daughter like dat…and if u reali wanna kno wat i think write me in a eamil…and yea my commment deservers 2 b herd and yea im only 14 years old…..

    53. kim on December 13th, 2008 9:38 am

      I’d like to know why it took the GRANDMOTHER 31 days to report her GRANDCHILD that lives in her home missing. I lived with my parents as a single mom and they saw my son EVERY DAY. Picked him up from school and helped out with his homework. I’d like to think that if my mother hadn’t seen him in, OH, I don’t know….3 days or so she’d be frantic and DEMANDING answers at that point. Something is not right here.

    54. kim on December 13th, 2008 9:47 am

      I’d like to know why it took the GRANDMOTHER 31 days to report her granddaughter, who lives in her home, missing. I lived with my parents as a single mom. They would pick my son up from school and help with his homework. They saw him EVERY DAY. I’d like to think that if my mother hadn’t seen her grandchild in, Oh, I don’t know, 1 or 2 days….she’d be DEMANDING ANSWERS FROM ME AND ON THE PHONE WITH THE POLICE AT THAT POINT. Another thing, the parents believed Casey had a job at Universal Studios. Well, if you have a job YOU TYPICALLY DON’T RUN OUT OF GAS ALL OVER THE PLACE. YOU HAVE MONEY. Something is NOT right here. Talk about a family wearing “blinders” and not seeing what in the hell is going on.

    55. CAROLYN EVERIDGE on December 27th, 2008 10:46 pm

      wha is wih thes people, their grandbaby is ea, and they re still keeing atight lip

    56. CAROLYN EVERIDGE on December 27th, 2008 10:48 pm

      this family is really werd, what is their problem, I wouldnt lie for anybody least ofall my family…

    57. Casey Anthony & Murder of Caylee Anthony … Cindy and George Anthony go on Larry King Live with Atty Conway | Scared Monkeys on May 14th, 2009 7:45 am

      [...] that you have done and said. Was it not you Cindy who said at the outset of this case that “the trunk smelled like death?” Oh that’s right Cindy, it was [...]

    58. Debby on April 9th, 2010 1:50 pm

      We all should know that Casey Anthony is a LIAR!! She has made up so many stories. But by now we also know that she is dead!!! And now Casey is still lying, and now they found out that Caylee was given drugs to make her sleep, she needs to STOP LYING!!

    59. Casey Anthony Attorney Jose Baez Says This Case Will Not Define Him on Verge of Jury Selection … Wanna Bet! | Scared Monkeys on May 8th, 2011 2:04 pm

      [...] Anthony murder case is doing going to define Baez’s career, must also think that the trunk that smelled like a dead body was in it, really does think it was a pizza. He maintained he is committed to the case, but [...]

    60. Casey Anthony Murder Trial Day 4: Simon Birch, Mgr of Towing Yard Says Casey Anthony’s Car Smelled of Decomposition … George Anthony, “I Feared Car Death Smell Was Casey, Caylee.” | Scared Monkeys on May 28th, 2011 10:45 am

      [...] We will remember back in 2008, this is the same day that George Anthony drove the car home. Cindy Anthony would call 911 to report Caylee missing where she told the 911 dispatcher, “It smells like there’s been a dead body in the damn car.” [...]

    61. Jonothon on October 10th, 2011 11:43 am

      Casey Anthony is a filthy liar that has told stories to the police ever since caylee was reported missing. You don’t lie about your own daughter missing unless you know what happened to her because it would be pointless to lie if you didn’t do it.Casey should be in jail right now but it’s not her fault the prosecution didn’t put her away. You have to give credit to the defense team because they did their job. Yes we want to hurt casey but why? We know she did it but it not her fault the police couldnt prove her to be guilty. We should be mad at the prosecutors for not doing their job by using evidence. They didn’t have enough evidence to prove her guilty so now she has the chance to live her life now!!!

    Leave a Reply

    Support Scared Monkeys! make a donation.

    • NEWS (breaking news alerts or news tips)
    • Red (comments)
    • Dugga (technical issues)
    • Dana (radio show comments)
    • Klaasend (blog and forum issues)
    E-mail It