ARUBA SINKS TO NEW LOW … Think This Isn’t Slander and Libel? … Daniel Young and Kelly Castillo Claim Natalee Holloway abused by stepfather Jug Twitty



Aruba … do you wish to ever have another American tourist ever come to your island again. If not, keep it up.

So the Aruban authorities and media would listen to the rantings of two American “mediums” rather than properly investigate the disappearance of Natalee Holloway. Hopefully, the national media will pick up on this story so that the whole world can see how Aruba treats tourists who “something bad happens to.” 

Not even Minister Croes, who at that time, two years ago, called them ‘Indian stories’.   It was Tourism-minister Edison Briesen that introduced them to Croes, because he thought that the information was important enough to be included in the judicial investigation.  Croes is of the opinion that now that the case against the suspects Joran and the brothers Deepak and Satish Kalpoe has brought no results, the Public Prosecution must also consider other scenarios.

Daniel Young_Kelly Castillo

(Daniel Young and Kelly Castillo – They are not detective, they are mediums)

Daniel Young and Kelly Castillo claim that Natalee’s stepfather Jug Twitty had abused Natalee, got her pregnant and that Beth knew of it. They go on to blame the family for for knowing that Natalee died two weeks after her night on the beach with Joran Van der Sloot. Some people will do anything to get attention. It would also appear that Aruba would sink to the lowest depths to go after people’s character to protect their tourism. Everybody knows that the Aruban officials botched the investigation, either through incompetence or purposely. You would now sink to this level!

Daniel Young and Kelly Castillo in the disappearance case of Natalee Holloway, must be seriously considered.  The two assert that Natalee’s stepfather Jug Twitty has abused and impregnated her and that her mother Beth knew about it.  The two also say that Natalee had died from an overdose two weeks after the night on the beach with Joran van der Sloot when she disappeared.  “Joran is innocent”, said the investigators.


 Natalee abused by stepfather Jug , Amigoe: 1/18/2008

This time, the local media has paid plenty of attention to the story of Dan Young and Kelly Castillo.

ORANJESTAD — Minister Rudy Croes (MEP) of Justice is of the opinion that the findings of the two American investigators Daniel Young and Kelly Castillo in the disappearance case of Natalee Holloway, must be seriously considered.  The two assert that Natalee’s stepfather Jug Twitty has abused and impregnated her and that her mother Beth knew about it.  The two also say that Natalee had died from an overdose two weeks after the night on the beach with Joran van der Sloot when she disappeared.  “Joran is innocent”, said the investigators. 

It appears from this computer printout that Beth Twitty has lied about her arrival time in Aruba.

The two private detectors could be elaborately heard and seen on radio and TV in local current affairs programs yesterday.  TeleAruba spent half of her daily news program on an interview with Castillo and Young, who also call themselves ‘mediums’.  They were also in Aruba last year, but there was hardly any attention paid to their stories.  Not even Minister Croes, who at that time, two years ago, called them ‘Indian stories’.   It was Tourism-minister Edison Briesen that introduced them to Croes, because he thought that the information was important enough to be included in the judicial investigation.  Croes is of the opinion that now that the case against the suspects Joran and the brothers Deepak and Satish Kalpoe has brought no results, the Public Prosecution must also consider other scenarios.  Castillo and Young’s findings must therefore be seriously investigated, said the minister.  “After Beth has been in Oprah’s program, it will be good to tell the other side of the story.”   Oprah Winfrey has spent some time on the Holiday-matter in her show yesterday. 


The real relationship between Natalee and her parents must be investigated.  The American investigators say that they have proof that Natalee was sexually abused by her stepfather Jug and was even pregnant from him.  “Beth and Jug (in the meantime divorced, red.) are doing everything possible to keep this family-secret hidden.  Fact is that Natalee didn’t want to go home after her vacation in Aruba.  And Beth knew that”, said Young.  Beth’s best friend, Carol Standifer had told the two investigators that she knew about the sexual abuse.  “We have that conversation on tape.  We also have proof that Beth didn’t arrive in Aruba at 23:00, but at 20:15 by air.  She already knew that her daughter didn’t want to return home.” 

That also appears from the original poster that Beth had already made in the United States, says Young.  “This poster didn’t mention the word ‘kidnapping’ at all, like it was the case with later posters.  It stated: ‘Natalee call, big hooty is on the island; call big hooty, we have to talk’.”  The two investigators say that they have received the poster from the then leader of investigation, Karin Janssen.  “Beth writes in her book that the kidnapping posters are the first ones that she has circulated in Aruba.  But we know that that’s not true, and so does a huge number of Aruban people that have seen the first poster hung everywhere.  Only in the United States, nobody knows this.” 

Beth had lied, because she was afraid that the authorities would not have worked so hard on the disappearance case if they knew that the relationship between her and her daughter was bad.  She also wanted to avoid that the investigation would concentrate on the family relations.

Natalee was still alive when her parents arrived in Aruba.  “Joran has indeed left her on the beach, but she then made friends with some other people that had helped her go into hiding.  She definitely didn’t want to go back and she remained a few weeks in San Nicolas.  There’s where she had finally died from an overdose, as Dompig (police commissioner Gerold Dompig that led the police investigation, red.) had already said.” 

Together with journalists of Aruba Today, they went to the location where Natalee’s body was supposedly buried.  “The police didn’t believe us, but when we showed them the location, they immediately realized that something was not right.  They were going to come back with dogs the next day to explore the place, but they never did”, said Young.


Dompig indicated that he has never talked to the two Americans during the investigation, but that he does know who they are.  “Wild cowboys, that’s what I thought of them.  They spent a lot of time with Angela and Julia (Angela Munzenhofer and Julia Renfro; journalists of Aruba Today, red.) and every day had the wildest indications.”  Dompig received so many information at that time that he saw no reason to further investigate Castillo and Young’s findings.  Looking back now he says that he regrets that ‘the two have made their entry in a wrong manner’.  “The story about sexual abuse explains in any case Jug’s conduct.  He was very aggressive and threatened me and other police officers.” 

The police have also indications like the first poster that Beth circulated and from stories of her friends about the relation between mother and daughter being disturbed, says Dompig.  Whether Beth had lied about her arrival time in Aruba, he doesn’t know.  “We have investigated the timeline and based on telephone conversations, flight information and flight movements, we know that these must match in theory and that Beth had arrived at the time she said she did.”

Dompig doesn’t dare say whether the two are integer, but from his former FBI-contact he knows that Castillo and Young have never had cases that can be considered serious.  “In America, everybody can call himself private investigator, and I know that they do not represent much and are probably looking for their 15 minutes of fame.”  But I still think that they may have found some things.  “You never know.  Besides, people say that children and fools cannot lie.” 


Julia Renfro told the Amigoe that the two Americans are ‘disturbed’ and that she doesn’t want to have anything to do with them.  “They have also accused me of complicity in the death of Natalee.” 

Castillo and Young have publicly accused Renfro on television yesterday that she has withheld information from them.  ”We are aware of your problems and one day you will have to tell the truth.  This is not healthy and people that do this, become alcoholic or drug addicts.  Julia, give us back our tape”, said Young on TeleAruba yesterday. 


The American presenter didn’t spend an entire programme on Beth Twitty and her book Loving Natalee that according to several sources, is not selling well.  Twitty had 15 minutes broadcasting time, and also Natalee’s brother the 18-year old Matt Holloway had the opportunity to say something.  He has knowingly remained behind the scenes all this time and he said that his friends have supported him during this ‘terrible period’.   

Also Natalee’s friends mentioned their loss and said how cheerful and special Natalee was.  The broadcasting was for the rest a repetition of events.  Beth said though that she had wanted to talk to Joran if he had consented to a lie-detector test.  The recent wine incident in the Pauw & Witteman programme was no surprise for her.  “What he did confirms how I think of him.”

She didn’t comment on whether she still considers Joran and the brothers Kalpoe as suspects.  “I would like to look outside the existing circle of suspects, but everything continues to point at these three boys.”


If you liked this post, you may also like these:

  • Aruba Sinks to New Lows, Part II … Tourism-minister Edison Briesen that introduced them to Justice Minister Croes
  • Scared Monkeys Radio Daily Commentary – Monday, January 21, 2008 – “Mediums” Daniel Young and Kelly Castillo Channel B.S. In Natalee Holloway Case
  • Natalee Holloway; Afternoon Update
  • So Aruba Wants to Question the Time Line of Beth Holloway and Not that of Three Suspects in her Daughters Disappearance?
  • New witnesses in Aruba; Credible or Just another Story

  • Comments

    82 Responses to “ARUBA SINKS TO NEW LOW … Think This Isn’t Slander and Libel? … Daniel Young and Kelly Castillo Claim Natalee Holloway abused by stepfather Jug Twitty”

    1. Sherry on January 19th, 2008 9:53 am

      If I were Beth and/or Jug I do believe I would sue for slander. These people are nuts.

    2. Kat on January 19th, 2008 10:04 am

      HMMMMMM !!! I think Jug should take a Lie Detector test. Prove he is innocent or GUILTY !!!

    3. Peter Andre on January 19th, 2008 10:10 am

      Aruba doesnt have to worry u Americans love drugs and sex u will come anyway

      SM: Wait til this story makes the wires … It isn’t the low hanging fruit that tourist islands seek my delusional friend. You are a sick soul.


    4. Scared Monkeys on January 19th, 2008 10:15 am

      ARUBA has sunk to news stories from MOON BATS.


      There is a reason why these people were never listened to. Nothing has changed to make their story any less beyond insane as it was originally.

      Everybody knows who is responsible for Natalee’s disappearance … Don’t you Rudy Croes!

    5. waterboy (Jerry) on January 19th, 2008 10:32 am

      Pluck the feathers from 100 of the oldest and stinkiest chickens know to man; heat a tub containing 19 ½ pounds of good asphalt grade tar; hire 2 mounted cowboys with good roping skills.

      It’s time for an old fashion tar and feathering.



    6. waterboy (Jerry) on January 19th, 2008 10:42 am

      Peter #3,

      Sounds like you know the combo well. That is deviant sex and bad drugs. The bad drugs have caused only intermittent firing of the neurons in your brain, and the deviant sex has caused a rapid progression to tertiary syphilis.

      Seek help at once! You could hurt yourself by just thinking too much.


    7. Jerry from Ohio on January 19th, 2008 10:49 am

      I am not a big Fan of our judicial system in all regards but I do believe that truth can be discerned in the majority of our courts so in these two have proof positive then let them come forth with it in American courts and allow the Twittys there time also to see if these two (investigators ) REALLY have what they claim too .

    8. waterboy (Jerry) on January 19th, 2008 10:57 am


      Let your hair down out of that tight weaved bouffant, It’s cutting off blood flow to your brain.


    9. buster on January 19th, 2008 11:31 am

      aruba: Expect the worse

    10. mommytraveler on January 19th, 2008 11:41 am

      OK – If we are to believe this fantasy – take it one step further – WHERE IT NATALEE?

      OH – You don’t know? But you do KNOW that Jug was involved. HMMMMMMMMMmmmmmmmmm.

      This, obviously, does not pass the “smell” test plunging Aruba’s reputation down to a new low. I wonder how much they were paid to spread this story.

    11. JusticeforNatalee on January 19th, 2008 11:54 am

      Wow–Red, you are right! If the American media
      broadcasts this latest nonsense, it will be curtains for Aruba.

      Here is the message the American public will get–

      If your daughter goes to Aruba and gets killed, you won’t get justice. Instead, she will be blamed or there will be lies made up about your family. You will have to suffer each day wondering where your daughter’s remains are. If you want to find her,
      you will have to look yourself or rely on other Americans.
      Meanwhile, Aruba will play catch and release with the prime suspects.

      Overall message from the media : Don’t go to Aruba.
      Just don’t go. This travesty will happen to you.

      Bye bye tourism.

    12. KrisG on January 19th, 2008 12:19 pm

      #11 Justice: You are right. How much more will the Holloway/Twitty families have to endure? I hope Nancy G., Kimberly G. and Geraldo, just to name a few, pick up on this fantasy and grill these people on their shows.

      Just one more reason to say: SHAME ON YOU ARUBA!

    13. Sharon Fetters on January 19th, 2008 12:31 pm

      The TV Show Haunting Evidence goes to Aruba and the fingers are pointed to the three suspects as the murderers of Natalee Holloway….

      Then these two clowns come and turn the tables against the Twitty/Holloway families. Just two more clowns to add to Aruba’s continuous circus acts.

      Keep promoting the injustices you have toward Natalee, Aruba and the only thing you will have left to export or offer is sand.

      I wonder how much these two are getting paid?
      Free lodging 24/7 at the hotels and airfare? Friends of J. Renfrog?

    14. Sharon Fetters on January 19th, 2008 12:34 pm

      I too hope that Jug and Beth sue for slander. These nuts better fasten their safety belts its going to be a bummpy ride…. Looking for Fame and Fortune…

    15. Kat_Gram on January 19th, 2008 12:38 pm

      These two better have some insurance for libel.
      I have been reading up on libel and they persons who allow them to transmit this libel could well, be sued also.

    16. kayjay on January 19th, 2008 12:59 pm

      Good morning Jossy,
      Your comments please.

    17. brie on January 19th, 2008 1:02 pm

      That is disgraceful…Jug is going to want a piece of you….
      Isn’t it very typical of Aruba to always put the blame somewhere else…Joran exposed himself and the media gave that a lot of attention….their just trying to divert the attention and blame the victim and anyone else associated.

    18. JusticeforNatalee on January 19th, 2008 1:02 pm

      Just posted in the forum by GEL/Originally posted by
      Angelalala @BFN

      email from Aruba

      The spiritualists had an appointment with the largest radio station on the island (Canal 90) yesterday, but did not show up. The director called me to ask whether I knew that it was a member of this very corrupt government who brought them here. I confirmed his suspicions. It was the son of the former MInister of Justice (Hendrik Croes) and nephew of the present MInister of Justice (Rudy Croes) who made all the arrangements. However, theirs was a one-day show that blew up in their faces. So much for that!

    19. brie on January 19th, 2008 1:09 pm

      Let’s put Haunting Evidence and these 2 screwballs together and see what happens!

      Amigoe…that is about the biggest piece of smut I have ever read….Shame on You

    20. Cindy on January 19th, 2008 1:19 pm

      Wow, you two “mediums”…how does it feel to join the list of the most hated people in America? Whenever Scared Monkeys runs an article about Natalee they seem to get more comments from readers than any other story. So just how many people are reading about your stupidity and cruelty to her family? The money you made will only last so long but the ridiculous reputation you have created for yourselves will go on forever. Not that anyone has every believed anything you had to say in the past but you surely will never be taken seriously ever again.

    21. minnesota dad on January 19th, 2008 1:28 pm

      Keep on spinning Aruba….keep on spinning.

      It was a busy week with Oprah and Joran causing so much more trouble to Aruba. The Crisis Management PR team decided to dust off these paid shills to come up with a story that they can continue to pump out to the locals in Aruba.


      Stop spinning and confess Aruba.


    22. brie on January 19th, 2008 1:39 pm

      You morons….what are you wacked out on?????? That was a malicious attempt to hurt, even beyond cruelty. Watch out….paybacks are hell!

    23. Miss-Underestimated on January 19th, 2008 1:51 pm

      JQK, I hope he is listening.

      Let Aruba keep up this shit….it only will qualify that Aruba is hiding something.

      PS another deserted day on the deserted island.

      Hey Daniel and Kelly guess what I am thinking?

    24. Scared Monkeys on January 19th, 2008 1:53 pm

      I am actually ashamed for ever having met or known you Rudi Croes.

      Rudi, your brother Betico is rolling over in his grave.

    25. Richard on January 19th, 2008 2:05 pm

      Let’s hope that we get some reaction, swift and furious, from Aruba on this. Otherwise, let them all stew in their sewer.

      And if the Aruban press won’t denounce this … then it just shows, once again, the caliber of Aruba and its people.

      Now, who was it who was saying about the boycott, “But what about those poor innocent Arubans?”

      Send them all to hell, far as I care.

      By the way, is there anything new on that American woman missing in Curacao? Or is that case, too, destined to be written off?

    26. Richard on January 19th, 2008 2:21 pm

      Looks like my post vanished … anyway, to keep it short, I will expect a swift and serious rebuke by the Aruban government to all this BS.

      If it isn’t forthcoming … who was it who said we should feel sorry for the damage that the boycott is causing the “poor innocent Arubans”?

      Let Julia Renfro and her other Aruban media whores lead the whole place to Hell.

      No pity, no mercy for any of them after this garbage is published.

      And let Americans who think of going to Aruba take note … YOU will be blamed for anything that happens to you.

      Just like, I’m sure, will be the case with that American woman who vanished on Curacao. Interesting how that case has dropped out of the media already … surprise, surprise.

    27. JusticeforNatalee on January 19th, 2008 2:32 pm


      This is why you need to show up
      at the travel shows in Boston and NY.

      Stand up for Natalee!
      Warn other tourists!

      All NY area and New England monkeys:
      We need you! Natalee needs you!

      Put your immense dedication into action!
      It’s a great experience you won’t ever forget.

      contact Vicki:

    28. Scared Monkeys on January 19th, 2008 2:39 pm

      Hey AMIGOE, whats the matter you ashamed of the story you put up on the English version?

      Amigoe never updates their stories that fast. Its already off.

      Last weekend fridays stories were on to like the following Tuesday.

      Too bad, the story has been saved for all to see.

    29. benh on January 19th, 2008 2:41 pm


    30. 10061906 on January 19th, 2008 2:53 pm

      kat 2: IMO; Joran should go first, then Deepak, then Satish, then Paulus, then van der Straaten, then Freddy, then Koen, then Sander, then Geoff, then Michael, them Croes, then Odubar, then Jorge and then Stepanie.
      If the lie detector hasn’t blown a fuse by then; maybe Jug will be accomodating.
      However; I can’t speak for him.

    31. JusticeforNatalee on January 19th, 2008 2:54 pm

      Red, do they HAVE any shame?
      Probably trying to avoid a lawsuit is more like it.
      I see many potential ones.

      Would I be correct in saying that
      any media (or even an individual)
      promoting this libelous crap, knowing full well it
      is a big lie, would ALSO be held accountable?

    32. nurturer on January 19th, 2008 3:01 pm

      Even if some of this were true . . . what is to be gained by saying so?

      As aleady mentioned, the way to squash this is for Beth and Jug to sue this pair for slander. In a court they would have to provide their evidence, and not having any, they would be put in their place AND be made an example of, to say nothing of having ‘lighter pockets’.

      I would think Beth and Jug have gone through their share of pain already. It’s time they start dishing out some of their own. Crushing these two GOOFS would be a good place to start.

      Oh, and by the way . . .

      . . . love the tats!

    33. JusticeforNatalee on January 19th, 2008 3:10 pm

      Wow, Aruba! Just WHERE is your PR advice coming from?
      You are flushing money down the toilet. It’s almost as if you want to RUIN your own tourism.

      Again, free advice, Aruba:
      Justice for Natalee

      THAT’S how you help tourism.

    34. diverboy on January 19th, 2008 3:14 pm

      Maybe this Daniel Young fellow should tell Jug these things face-to-face. These people are not “mediums”..they are “X-Large”…a-holes, that is….looking for a hand-out.

    35. brie on January 19th, 2008 3:15 pm

      Rudy Croes that is a dirty deal, a really dirty deal, you, Anita and Paulus are behind that. I hope the Dutch ditch you for that one. You want independence from the Netherlands….you just might get it. Go back to Colombia and join your gorillas….and I’m not referring to the sacred Animal Kingdom either, that would be an insult to all animals!!!!

      Your a complete failure as Minister of Justice, the word doesn’t exist in your vocabulary!!!!

    36. brie on January 19th, 2008 3:22 pm

      Article in Arubagrip referring to these two demons by Diario….Jossy says his views remain unchanged concerning Joran and the Kalpoes.

    37. Para2legal on January 19th, 2008 3:24 pm

      I have the feeling that The Persistence must be very close to finding Natalee and Aruba is putting this spin out for when she’s found. They’re throwing s___ on a wall and seeing what will stick. Reading the whole article was too sickening but isn’t that Arlene
      s. doing the interview…ha, ha – how many times did she look straight into Greta’s camera and tell lies? These people are beyond sick. Boycott the evil disgusting perverted island until it sinks.

    38. Crimson on January 19th, 2008 3:35 pm

      I’m getting a vision… A vision not of the past, but one of the near future: ‘Aruba’s economy will crumble due to the severe lack of the American Tourist dollar’.

      Aruba will do absolutely anything in attempt to divert the attention away from their botched/cover up investigation. How many more BS theories are they going to shovel our way expecting us to be ignorant enough grab a spoon and dig in.

      It doesn’t take a psychic to see that these 2 ‘mediums’ are a pair of extra large frauds, they need to slither back under the slimy rock they emerged from.

    39. brie on January 19th, 2008 3:35 pm

      Couple of real evil spirits, aren’t they? Natalee never ran away….but the two of you might seriously want to think about it!

    40. Scared Monkeys on January 19th, 2008 3:41 pm


      A news paper does have free speech to hide behind, however, to be so irresponsible to have a one sided story with no mention of trying to contact the other side is beyond irresponsible.

      They should be ashamed.

      There is a reason why no one listened to these people in the past.

      Does anyone wonder how many lunatics come forward with stories when cases occur? People actually admit to crimes they did not commit.

      That does not mean the police arrest them and they are tried for the crime.

      Mental disease is alive and well … so is the continued effort by those in Aruba to cover up and smear the family.

    41. molly in houston on January 19th, 2008 4:10 pm

      Bunch of CRUEL FREAKS!! I hope they get sued. I hope “something bad happens” to them. Disgusting.

      boycott Aruba

      molly in houston

    42. Melissa on January 19th, 2008 4:13 pm

      Nothing could surprise me that came out of or happened in Aruba. My good dear friend Wayne Benson always said he never experienced a place where gossip and hearsay are believed and circulated as the truth.

      I need to get more information but I had friends who were on a Holland America cruise a couple of weeks ago and after stopping in Aruba – norovirus and they were confined to their cabins for five days.

    43. dennisintn on January 19th, 2008 4:14 pm

      #24, red, i’m really curious. when you met rudy, did you get any clues or vibes that he would invent, or participate, in this kind of garbage? you know, head spins all the way around, green foam at the mouth.

    44. on January 19th, 2008 5:04 pm

      I’m stunned. American media didn’t put this pair on because we have slander and libel laws and while indeed the press gets a free pass on a lot of things, even the most vile American press has more responsibility than to test our laws on libel and slander.

      I thought I’d seen everything Aruba could possibly dish out. Fascinating that these type of claims were being posted over on the Oprah board just before her show with Beth aired.

      Natalee Ann Holloway sexually abused by Jug and yet Beth and Dave stood by and said nothing? Not only that, anyone want to believe that a girl as strong as Natalee would allow herself to be sexually abused? Not in a million years.

    45. anne on January 19th, 2008 5:24 pm

      These two begin the interview by saying in 2005, we had information and things were different, then, in 2006, things were different again and then in 2007, things were different again. We have information… Julia Renfro, you know things, please tell them…

      These two allude to knowing facts — but really, if they have all these tape recordings and other facts, why don’t they make them public? What kind of special information have they been privy to each year? Why state their case only alluding to what they heard without backing it up with evidence – like tape recordings they say they have? What is it that Julia Renfro won’t come forward with? It’s almost like these two are putting forth a case without actually stating the facts.

      Very disturbing. If these two have more information than is out there, they should lay it out with the specifics they “claim” to have. They loose all credibility with their broad, yet secretive, statements. Oh yeah, and they also loose all credibility by saying that Aruba bought and paid for their services!

    46. buster on January 19th, 2008 5:25 pm

      #40 like the guy who said he killed the lil Ramsey angel

    47. mayan_moons on January 19th, 2008 5:29 pm

      Hey Para2legal…..i’m also getting the feeling that The Persistence may be getting to close to finding Natalee. Not because of this trash they’re talking & printing about Jug or even that Jipshit threw wine in Peter’s face….noo what sent my antena up was the port of Aruba radioing The Persistence to assist in the search for a sailboat called The Michelle. I mean come on…Aruba has a coast guard crew and helicopter’s to search by air yet none of that was done. Nooo instead they radio The persistence. Could that be coz the crew is getting close and a diversion was needed in hopes to steer the ship away from the grid they were on? I know one thing…..i haven’t heard nor read one word about The Michelle being found & rescued nor one word about the people on the sailboat….their names……NOTHING!

    48. nurturer on January 19th, 2008 5:35 pm

      A lawsuit will fix this. BIG TIME.

    49. brie on January 19th, 2008 6:16 pm

      Mayan you could very well be right…the Persistence may have been on the right grid and steered away because of a boat in distress. Per Aruban port authorities. And not a word since!!!!

    50. brie on January 19th, 2008 6:17 pm

      Those two gypsies will take the money and run and pitch a tent somewhere else!

    51. Maggie on January 19th, 2008 6:54 pm

      Dompig shot his own saying to pieces. Fools can’t lie.. haha..This whole story is a bunch of fools lying. Everytime they open their mouths, they shoot themselves in the foot. He goes on to say children can’t lie.. LOL.. helloooo, wasn’t it his child that got Guido or Cromvoit arrested for heavy battery against Natalee.. Dompig later went out to say, well his son Michael lied. You know Michael seen trying to pick up American tourists and Joran’s friend. Dompig what happened to Guilty as Hell or hold your breath 24 hours, big developments. Waaaaa Jug was agressive and threatened them. Don’t take long to figure out who the fools and liars are in this story. Who in their right mind would send their daughter to this hell hole now?

      Dompig doesn’t dare say whether the two are integer, but from his former FBI-contact he knows that Castillo and Young have never had cases that can be considered serious. “In America, everybody can call himself private investigator, and I know that they do not represent much and are probably looking for their 15 minutes of fame.” But I still think that they may have found some things. “You never know. Besides, people say that children and FOOLS CAN”T LIE.”

      DOMPIG: . So sometimes people will ask us that, “Are you not tunnel-visioned? Maybe you should look at other possibilities.” Of course. We did that. But we still feel that, every time you go on a path, a different path, that path leads back, comes back to these three boys.

      GEROLD DOMPIG, DEPUTY POLICY CHIEF OF ARUBA: I still believe that these boys have been lying. They’re still lying. And everybody knows that by now. So there’s no doubt in my mind that they know something, they are guilty of something.
      March 26, 2006

      Dompig laid out the latest scenario of what happened after Natalee was last seen driving off with van der Sloot and the Kalpoe brothers shortly after 1 a.m. He says investigators think the group did not go to the beach but that they possibly brought Natalie back to the Van der Sloots home.

      ABRAMS: We have heard from official statements from the authorities in Aruba that Joran Van Der Sloot made inconsistent statements. True?

      DOMPIG: That is correct.

      ABRAMS: What were they inconsistent about?

      DOMPIG: Well, it would take me, I think, a little over two days to go over all the inconsistencies. None of the stories match up, let me put it that way. So when it comes to believing this individual, we know in which category to place him.

      The F.B.I. profiled him as a person who never has been corrected by his parents. He’s the boss of what happens in that house. He’s the boss in the family. He is allowed to do anything.. If a person like that is in a position where a person says, ‘No,’ well, that person may change completely. Maybe he blew a fuse when she wouldn’t have sex with him, and something happened.

      Dompig says he believes Paulus Van Der Sloot does know more than he has been telling about the circumstances surrounding Holloway’s disappearance.

      Deputy Police Commissioner, Gerold Dompig, told The Associated Press that one of three young men arrested in the case admitted “something bad happened” to Holloway and was leading police to the scene. Prosecutors refused to comment on Dompig’s statement, and Dompig himself refused to identify which of the three young men who took Holloway to the Northern beach the night she went missing made the statement.

      DOMPIG: .They keep denying it, and they only went so far as to say that they fondled sexually. At least, Joran did that, and the others denied everything.

      COSBY: Now, did Joran-we’ve heard from the family, Chief, that-you know, that Joran was claiming in some statement that she was going in and out of consciousness. Have you seen that anywhere?

      DOMPIG: Yes. That’s definitely in the statements, and that’s why we were kind of disappointed when the judge didn’t accept that because that’s basically a felony in Aruba. We think that what happened was that the judge just didn’t buy it the way-because Joran went back and forth with his statements, and he withdrew two statements which he had already given to us. So basically, none of his statements were really trustworthy.

      Despite seeking information on the family, Dompig said police “never stopped looking at our suspects being the three boys in Aruba, and there is no reason at all for us to focus on other individuals when we are speaking of suspects.”

      On 10-26 DOMPIG told “FoxNews that he believes NATALEE’s body is “either in a cage, or put weights on it, or something like that. If that is the case, we should be able to find something.”

      ARUBA (Crime Library) – For a missing person and probable murder case that is almost a year old, it seems like there is news almost on a daily basis. Recently, several Dutch legal experts were openly critical of the investigation into the disappearance of Natalee Holloway conducted by Aruba’s Deputy Chief of Police Gerold Dompig. Dompig was removed from the case last week. Adolpho Richardson replaced him as the leader of the investigation.

      Professor of criminal law Menno Dolman told the Dutch GDP news agency that he could not comprehend why there was no immediate search for Natalee after her disappearance. In a translated summary of various Dutch papers that appeared on the missing persons blog Scared Monkeys, another expert, law psychologist Peter van Koppen told reporters that it was “very peculiar that it was only after Dompig got an anonymous tip about a possible location of Natalee’s body that police began to search for her. “Usually, the area gets cordoned off immediately, in order to dig and obtain samples.

    52. Patti on January 19th, 2008 7:08 pm

      Rudy Croes will give credence to anyone or anything that causes confusion in the minds of the American public or points the finger in ANY direction, other than Aruba!



      Hey Rudy:

      What were you doing in the Chicago videos when the body of a young lady was removed from a rock, bagged-up and put in the water basin… nothing!


      Boycott Aruba

    53. Aruba Sinks to New Lows, Part II … Tourism-minister Edison Briesen that introduced them to Justice Minister Croes | Scared Monkeys on January 19th, 2008 7:28 pm

      [...] mornings article, ARUBA SINKS TO NEW LOW … Think This Isn’t Slander and Libel? … Daniel Young and …, would have been so long to write we have decided to break it up into numerous [...]

    54. Patti on January 19th, 2008 7:33 pm


      Yeah, right…

      Let’s get the step father of a girl that has been missing for over two years and make him take a lie detector test to clear his name from unsubstantiated “medium” hog wash.


      Lie detector tests are unreliable… it will take alot more than some nerve-racking test to proove anything as proposperous as this.

      They aren’t Mediums, only Attention Seekers?


    55. Maggie on January 19th, 2008 7:39 pm

      Kat, I might have taken you serious until you said, unless some of it is true???
      SM: JohnM strikes again. Post deleted (klaasend)

    56. Elaine on January 19th, 2008 7:54 pm

      hey#52…Kat…. Why don’t you run home now, Anita is waiting for you.
      SM: Just deleted that post. It was JohnM/GretaMal (klaasend)

    57. kayjay on January 19th, 2008 7:59 pm

      Thank you Jossy. Thank goodness for one voice of reason from Aruba.

    58. 10061906 on January 19th, 2008 8:59 pm

      51 Maggie: Everytime you/we go outside the box you/we alway come to the same conclusion JORAN.
      Yogi Berra had a perfect example.
      When you want to find the guilty…..
      His saying was; to get to his house.”when you come to the fork in the road take it”.

      It was a Y intersection and his street was a circle. The circle alsways comes back to JK2′S

    59. 10061906 on January 19th, 2008 9:04 pm

      mayan_moons 47:
      You took the words right out of my mouth.
      That too was the first thing that came to me.

    60. mayan_moons on January 19th, 2008 10:26 pm

      Heck yeah 1906…..before i even finished reading the article about The Michelle i got the feeling that this call for assistance was bogus. Aruba has atleast 3 helicopter’s that i know of soo why weren’t they sent out to search??

      We’re onto all your seedly little tactics Aruba and maaaaan does this story smack as being a ruse. They know American’s (the crew) would interupt their own mission to help save lives if needed and put it to the test and it worked. The crew tried to help the (so called) people adrift on this sailboat thus abandoning the search for Natalee for the day trying to help.

    61. mayan_moons on January 19th, 2008 10:42 pm

      Heck yeah 1906…..before i even finished reading the article about The Michelle i got the feeling that this call for assistance was bogus. Aruba has atleast 3 helicopter’s that i know of soo why weren’t they sent out to search??

      We’re onto all your seedly little tactics Aruba and maaaaan does this story smack as being a ruse. They know American’s (the crew) would interupt their own mission to help save lives if needed and put it to the test and it worked. The crew tried to help the (so called) people adreft on this sailboat thus abandoning the search for Natalee for the day trying to help.

    62. Patti on January 20th, 2008 1:07 am


      I wouldn’t put anything past them, either.

      Question is: Do they have the equipment to find and retrieve her?


      Dumb-Ass Indians…

      We’ll find her, if we haven’t already…


      Boycott Aruba


      Their Indian Stories!


      Hey Rudy!?!?

      Isn’t that like calling the skillet Black?

    63. mayan_moons on January 20th, 2008 1:30 am

      Yeah Patti… just smacks of another wild goose chase Aruban’s are famous for except this time its chasing tails on the water instead of the island to me.

    64. Patti on January 20th, 2008 3:18 am


      You once asked me who I thought killed Natalee…

      Beings that you are the first to see the body

      in the bush, would you agree with me?

      What are your thoughts?

    65. Patti on January 20th, 2008 3:44 am

      It took me a loooong time to finally figure it out. But once I did, everything fell into place. Even a free mind association that I did a long, long time ago. The hardest to interpret was the loin cloth. I kept thinking it had to be a towel that someone had placed over her buttock area. But if you look closely you will see how the blood pooled in the area of the waist, meaning that she had it on when she died.

      Once I understood that it was Indians, the loin cloth, finally, made sense. So I researched Indians of Aruba both on the internet and at the library. She was sacrificed by the Arawak Nation. And now, looking back… I see all kinds of places where the word Indian is mentioned in people’s statements, as if they WANTED us to know, or perhaps rub our noses in our unsatiable thirst for sex and drugs that we would have believed anything as long as it met our needs. Some even said that we would NEVER guess in a MILLION years.


    66. ausador on January 20th, 2008 4:33 am

      As mentioned above this is nothing more than an attempt to cast suspicion and doubt far and wide. The point is to move it away from the island of Aruba and onto the victim and/or her family. While I doubt that there is any real conspiracy of individuals or any government entity here, I do feel that there is a Con job being pepertrated.

      Daniel Young and Kelly Castillo are probably the most disgustingly vile, opportunistic, and glory seeking villians I have seen in the last twenty years. Whats worse is that if and when they read what I said above they will more than likely revel in it; as inhuman as they appear to be. Personally I believe that these two sub-human creatures waited until the constant media attention that they could never survive the scrutiny of in the United States had died down down to almost nothing. They understood that people within the government of Aruba needed a whipping dog, somewhere else to cast the blame, some way to say it was anothers fault. As Homer Simpson would say “DOH!”, yeah it is really easy to cast guilt and suspicion onto a missing and wordless victim. It is almost as easy to cast doubt onto thier immediate family since often it is an immediate family member who is responsible in many of these cases.

      We are conditioned to expect that when a wife disappears the husband did it, when the children disappear the wife did it, etc….etc….sigh :(

      We have reason to believe this, as your police or the F.B.I. will tell you it is statistically correct; so when a beautiful young girl disappears with no trace and no seeming reason and then someone comes along to tell you she was having “troubles at home”, perhaps even incest, then suddenly your mind locks onto the family as the possible cause of her disappearence. It is a calculated and rather disgusting attempt by two accomplished con artists to win favor with members of the Arubian government and to help them by casting doubt upon reality.

      So we are to believe that an inceteously knocked up Natalee died of a drug overdose two weeks after she was reported missing. Funny that with the entire island looking for her she was never found. Funnier still that with the traffic in and out of a typical crack house and the desperation of it’s average users no one ever saw or heard of her and attempted to collect the hugh reward. Even funnier still is how the operators of this supposed crack house made her body disappear into thin air after the search for her had already begun. I’ll put it this way, people how die in crack houses are found in an alley a few block away, they aren’t usually the subject of a magically disappearence.

      Young and Castillo are complete frauds and should be ashamed to be allowed themselves called ‘investigators’ by anyone. An investigator does not go on television saying that because a ‘friend of a nephew of the uncle of the victim told them the sky is mauve that it is fact.’ That is basically all they “alledge” here “supposedly” some unnamed people alledgedly told them certain things that would be considered heresy in a court of law. They have no proof at all, no credible witnesses or anyone willing to give them evidence useable in court in the form of a deposition.

      Now do you honestly think if this pair of fakirs actually had a story this hot and could prove it that they would be so stupid as to not document it? If you believe a word they say then you are the one that is being stupid. I can stand in front in front of press tomorrow and “say” that little orange men from pluto raped a girl, impregnated her, sent her to Aruba and then paid a wandering penguin to drag her out to sea and drown her. I can also “say” that certain unnamed friends of hers told me she was having problems at home. Then I can “say” that perhaps her father/step-father/uncle/brother/cousin/sister/aunt, was perhaps maybe possibly having sexual relations with her so maybe one of them paid off the penguin?

      This is all Daniel Young and Kelly Castillo are offering, unnamed sources and inexact accusations. They are not investigators at all they are frauds stirring the pot for a bit of personal fame and a little money. The sad thing is that by doing this they are widening the focus of the investigation away from those that really did it. Maybe they should try to prove they actually care about justice for Natalee by shutting up and getting out of the way, but they won’t. Sure, you say, but how do you know who did it?….well maybe the three men who have changed thier stories to the police 22 times about what happened that night? The last ones seen with her, the ones who traded text messages before they realized they were being investigated.

      Those three know what happened that night, Daniel Young and Kelly Castillo obviously don’t, but as long as it gets them media attention and free trips to Aruba I’m sure they will keep guessing.

      (BTW: Daniel/Kelly? Please sue me, I’d love to face you in court.)

    67. disgustedmom on January 20th, 2008 11:05 am

      Of all the dumb things to say. Even if Jug had abused Natalee that would only might make reason for her to be vulnerable to predators like Joran. I don’t believe Jug did though, but just saying if he did it can’t have anything to do with Natalee not being found dead or alive yet.

      I do wonder sometimes though as this ‘pregnant’ thing keeps rearing its ugly head if someone was afraid Natalee may have become pregnant after being raped on Aruba. If the perps did not use a condom and she was not on BC pills it may have become a very real fear that a little Joran may be stewing in the pot.

      Then these people, Y and C, mention Natalee dying after 2 weeks. Odd that is about how long it would take to find out if she were pregnant if she were raped on Aruba.

      Maybe she was held a couple weeks to find out. The test came back positive so she was murdered. HMMM?

    68. Guest on January 20th, 2008 11:16 am

      To 64, 65 – …a body in a bush? A loin cloth? Can you please explain?

    69. Patti on January 20th, 2008 4:23 pm


      Look for a body in the bush behind the painter.

      She is lying on her stomach with her left arm

      raised up in the air, like the statute of Liberty.

      Good Luck

    70. Patti on January 20th, 2008 4:25 pm


      Right on!

    71. Dave B. on January 20th, 2008 10:26 pm

      I regreat to say this, but I know Daniel Young and Kelly Castillo personally. Daniel claims to be a “Medium”, who communicates with deceased spirits. Kelly was not a medium, until she met Daniel and he became her mentor. So, long story short, almost all of the information those tow have regarding the disappearance of Natalee Holloway was “Given” to them through the spirit of Natalee and other deceased spitits. For several years they have tried to pass this information to the US media, but were turned down. “Wow, I wonder why”.

    72. Maggie on January 20th, 2008 10:56 pm

      Hellooooo Dave B.. I regreat to say I contacted a medium..and they told me you are FOS!

      SM: Maggie – I think Dave B is saying that Kelly and Daniel are FOS ;) (klaasend)

    73. Patti on January 20th, 2008 11:13 pm

      Dave B:

      Usually the reason the U.S. media doesn’t let people like these to vent their opinions on national t.v. is because there are laws against libel and slander. From the tone of your post, it sounds like you find their means of obtaining information hard to believe.

      One thing that I wonder is that Natalee didn’t have a troubled life which usually accompanies incestual sexual abuse. Contrary to what we know of the people that suffer from such abuse, Natalee’s life was one that was not only happy but successful, as well; as opposed to a life unraveling at the seams. I find it hard to believe that a teenager who is being sexually abused by a step-father could maintain a 4.0 grade point average, maintain a good relationship with her immediate and extended family, as well as be a leader among her peers.

      There is a word for those that hear voices:


      It does not surprise me that Aruba would allow these two to, openly, talk about matters that they have no proof in regards to Natalee Ann Holloway. Aruba has been attacking her and her family ever since she went missing on May 30, 2005.


      Justice for Natalee!


    74. Patti on January 20th, 2008 11:26 pm


      I think Aruba is desperate!




    75. Dave B. on January 20th, 2008 11:39 pm

      Yes Maggie, since I have known Daniel and Kelly for many years, I do believe and know that they are FOS. Personal experience, not from a medium. You ought to try it, the truth will set you free.

    76. Maggie on January 21st, 2008 12:29 am

      My apologies DaveB I thought you were saying they were telling the truth.. which I don’t believe any of it.. again I apologize to you:)

    77. david r on January 21st, 2008 2:49 pm

      While we have these two Aruban new hires around, let’s make sure to get their take on the Hoffa disappearance, the Kennedy assassination, the Bermuda Triangle, and Amelia Earhart. The pitiful thing is 20 years from now there will be a majority of Arubans who believe them. I’ll bet poor Beth has asked herself a million times ‘How could I ever have let my daughter go to such an evil place?’

    78. dennisintn on January 21st, 2008 5:10 pm

      there are kooks and crooks and liars in all societies. what gets me about these 2 coming to aruba is that the tourism minister and the justice minister brought them back and are supporting them, even though they know that all these allegations were debunked as lies during the summer of 06 by a.l.e, then klpd, and i suspect by the f.b.i. croes and briesen are just maliciously mounting an attack on natalee and her family because the family isn’t giving up, going home, shutting up, and getting over it. they want their daughter and justice for her, and that is not going to change.

    79. Dolf on January 23rd, 2008 10:51 am

      damn, I hope they stay there.

    80. Truthseeker on January 26th, 2008 2:52 am

      Ask not for whom the bell tolls, it tolls for Kat.

    81. Tina on October 16th, 2008 8:11 am

      I wonder how these two idiots feel about their disgusting comments now that Joran has confessed to dumping Natalie’s body. He raped and murdered her and has gotten away with it. And yet, people like Young and Castillo make profit by slandering grieving parents. How can they get away with this???? I am so disgusted. Why hasn’t anyone investigated these two corrupt people? Why has anyone not gone on their trail? Where they paid by the Aruban government or Joran’s family to distort the truth?

    82. met68 on April 12th, 2009 11:48 am

      Libel and slander? Its interesting to note that over one year later, there are no criminal charges levelled against Dan or Kelly. We need to begin examining this case with objectivity, and discard the hyperintensive emotionality currently imbuing it. There certainly is nothing illogical in what they are saying. Its at least worth investigating.

    Leave a Reply

    Support Scared Monkeys! make a donation.

    • NEWS (breaking news alerts or news tips)
    • Red (comments)
    • Dugga (technical issues)
    • Dana (radio show comments)
    • Klaasend (blog and forum issues)
    E-mail It