Robyn Gardner Missing in Aruba … New Witness Disputes Gary Giordano’s Claims that they Went Snorkeling Day She Disappeared

Robyn Gardner has been missing in Aruba since August 2, 2011. Her travel companion Gary Giordano’s told Aruba police that she went missing while they were snorkeling near Baby Beach.  However, according to the LE Giordano’s stories have been inconsistent. Giordano is presently being held in an Aruba jail as a suspect in the disappearance of Robyn Gardner.

According to a new witness who has come forward, they dispute the story that Gary Giordano has told regarding the fact that the two went snorkeling. The witness says that he was fishing the day that Giordano claims that he and Gardner were snorkeling. He states that the two walked on the beach, but never went into the water.

The witness says he was fishing on a beach on that day and he saw the two take a walk along the reef around 4 p.m., but they never went in the water.

A short time later, the couple drove away and he never saw either of them again, the witness says.

“If this witness ends up being accurate and correct as to locations of both Mr. Giordano and Ms. Gardner, it’s yet another piece of evidence that’s inconsistent with his story,” said ABC News consultant Brad Garrett, a former FBI agent.

So if the two never went snorkeling and only walked on the beach, when did  Robyn Gardner disappear? If a witness puts Gardner at the beach, that would mean that she could not have disappeared at an earlier time. Did no one else see the couple, no surveillance video, no one taking any pics or video, and what about the searching of Giordana’s rental car? The case of missing Robyn Gardner Missing is not Natalee Holloway. The Aruba police, tourism and authorities have no reason to cover up a crime for a “little Dutch boy” of privileged. Although, it would have been nice if Aruba had actually pursued the case of the disappearance of Natalee Holloway with some consistency. The words of Aruba Solicitor General Taco Stein that a charge of murder can be made without a body is quite different from “no body, no crime”, during the Holloway investigation.

The search for Gardner will resume Monday in Aruba. Her body would not have to be found in order for someone to be charged with her murder.

However, its Aruba … what will be next.

For more updates, analysis and to provide your own opinions, go to Scared Monkeys Missing Persons Forum: Robyn Gardner.