What is this? From this page you can use the Social Web links to save NY Times Reporting Style Comes to the Boston Globe to a social bookmarking site, or the E-mail form to send a link via e-mail.

Social Web


E-mail It
April 18, 2005

NY Times Reporting Style Comes to the Boston Globe

Posted in: General

It was only a matter of time before the New York Times methodology for reporting politically charged topics came to the Boston Globe. I am beyond being surprised by this. Actually, I am sure these practices are long standing, and it is only now because of Digital McCarthyites are out there that these fallacies are being brought out in the light.

Boston Globe told readers in an editor’s note published April 15 that portions of a story it ran on a seal hunt off Newfoundland and Labrador were fabricated by a freelance reporter who was not at the scene.

The Globe said the reporter, Barbara Stewart, did not attend the event, which had actually been postponed because of bad weather, and that Globe editors should have demanded attribution for details she provided about the hunt.

“The story should not have been published in the Globe, and the Globe has discontinued use of the freelancer,” the newspaper said in the editor’s note.

The article, published in April 13 editions of the Globe, said that the largest seal hunt in a half a century had resumed, involving hunters on about 300 boats “shooting at harp seal cubs by the hundreds, as the ice and water turned red.”

In its editor’s note, the Globe said: “The article included details of the day’s hunt as if it had taken place and without attribution or other source, as if the writer had witnessed the scene personally. … The author’s failure to accurately report the status of the hunt and her fabrication of details of the scene are clear violations of the Globe’s journalistic standards.”

Helen Donovan, executive editor, said the newspaper became aware there were problems with the story after it was contacted by the Canadian federal fisheries department.

Donovan said Stewart, who worked for The New York Times for about a decade, had written three pieces for the Globe since last year after moving to Halifax, Nova Scotia, and no other problems had occurred with her work.

Stewart did not return an e-mail message seeking comment.


Update: The actual correction can be found here.

Return to: NY Times Reporting Style Comes to the Boston Globe