SHOCKER … Casey Anthony’s One Night Stand with Co-Worker Josh Might be Caylee’s Dad


SHOCKER from the Casey/Caylee Anthony case … Caylee’s dad might have been a co-worker of Casey Anthony with who she had a one night stand with.

According to childhood friend Melina Calbrese, Casey Anthony told  her that Casey once slept with a man she worked with at Universal Studios named Josh and believed he was the father of her baby, Caylee. Casey Anthony would have a one night stand and get pregnant in the process? Say it isn’t so. Is it believable that such an event could occur? There is no truth to the rumor that Las Vegas casinos have that bet at even money. The infromation came from documents released on Friday, as well as info that Casey stole from Cindy.


Caution Sarcasm Alert: Who could possible believe Casey could have one night stand?

Calabrese said Anthony told her they’d had a one-night stand at a hotel near Universal Studios, where they both worked. Josh had a girlfriend he was planning to marry and already had a child.

Anthony told Calabrese the same story she relayed to her mother, Cindy Anthony: Caylee’s father died in a car crash about the time the toddler turned 2.

Anthony tried to hide her pregnancy until about the seventh month, according to the police documents released Friday.

More absurdity: Why are we not surprised that Leonard Padilla’s name would be mentioned as a potential buyer of the land that was recently put up for sale where the remains of Caylee Anthony was found. It is being reported that Padilla made a $50,000 offer for the property where Caylee’s remains were discovered. One would think that if Padilla truly cared about missing persons, he would make a $50K donation toward searches for other missing persons rather than just keeping his name in the headlines of the Caylee Anthony case.

Caylee Anthony land for sale

Karen Wonsetler, the attorney who represents the Chickasaw Oaks Phase Three Homeowners Association, said the community is “absolutely against” the bounty hunter’s idea to turn the land into a memorial for Caylee Marie.

“If we have a shrine literally in the middle of our association, it’s going to encourage unwanted traffic, unwanted attention,” she said. “We do not want this.”

Wonsetler said if the land was purchased and allowed to be turned into a permanent memorial, it would further burden the neighborhood.

If you liked this post, you may also like these:

  • Casey Anthony On Trial: Caylee’s Voice Heard, Finally.. Opening Arguments Commence
  • Florida Governor Rick Scott Signs “Caylee’s Law” … Missing Children Legislation Inspired by the Death of Caylee Anthony & Casey Anthony’s Lying to Police Makes It a Third Degree Felony
  • Caylee/Casey Case: Dominic Casey Takes Stand in Zenaida Gonzalez Case
  • Casey Anthony Not Allowed at Caylee’s Funeral and Anthony’s Supposedly Ask for Donations for Caylee’s Funeral
  • Caylee/Casey Anthony Case: Caylees Autopsy Revelations Part I

  • Comments

    21 Responses to “SHOCKER … Casey Anthony’s One Night Stand with Co-Worker Josh Might be Caylee’s Dad”

    1. Lexiwrites on March 22nd, 2009 10:19 pm

      Okay…I have heard so many names….Eric, Josh, Jesus, and I can’t even remember the rest. I won’t believe any of them until LE actually finds a positive match. As a matter of fact, I have to wonder if Casey really knows who the dad is. She seemed to jump from bed to bed almost daily. Since she denied the fact that she was pregnant for seven months, it would have to be hard to go back that far and try to remember who the current “flavor of the week” was. The only thing consistent….and I don’t believe this either…is that she seems to tell everyone that the dad died on Caylee’s birthday. She is quite the storyteller!

      Plus…what guy wants to come out of the woodwork now and say he could possibly be the daddy? It would seem to me like any guy who slept with her is hanging his head in shame for being strung along by this evil woman.

    2. Scared Monkeys on March 22nd, 2009 10:21 pm

      Is there anyone in Orange county that Casey may not have stole from?

      A one night stand … ya don’t say.


    3. Smarty Pants on March 23rd, 2009 3:39 am

      The name “JOSH” is a fake name made up by Casey to conseal the true name of Caylee’s father. If you listen to all the stories Casey gives to people about who the baby daddy is, you will see she has been fairly consistant with some parts of her story. It seems to be that Caseys MO is to give some truth to her tale while convoluting it with insignificant details she extrapulated from her friends or other people’s life events. So, all you have to do is follow her pattern of lies and focus on her half truths and apply it to the facts we do know or have learned to be the case. By applying this analysis I have summized a theory and opinion that the baby’s daddy is no other than “California Boy”. If you go back and read/research what has been reported of him and his relationship with Casey, then connect the dots of 1/2 truths, they will link you to the missing piece of the puzzle that Mark Hawkins is Caylee’d Dad.

    4. kimkoi on March 23rd, 2009 6:11 am

      She could be joshing…

    5. Susan on March 23rd, 2009 7:02 am

      I think she honestly doesnt know who the dad is! I think Cindy could of been pressuring her into Child Support, and Casey didnt want to get denied paternity for the second time, and go through the humiliation, in other words, she didnt want people to think bad ABOUT HER. (remember its all about her). So she cooked up this story to end her mothers nagging.

      Casey lies, she seems very sociopathic. Shes lying about Caylees murder because she doesnt want people to think shes a murderer, or think bad things about her. Its all about her, not about nobody else. She lies about everything from what I read, so theres a 90 percent chance Caylees father is a lie as well!

    6. BUN on March 23rd, 2009 8:25 am

      Where are all those guys came came out claiming to be Anna Nicole’s partner and the baby Daddy? Oh, wait, there was money involved and hey, there could be money here as well with all the selling of pics and movie rights, etc…

    7. Gigi on March 23rd, 2009 9:28 am

      if i were a man and i had slept with casey, i would keep my secret shame! what a circus and who wants to get involved in this murder investigation?? whoever slept with casey must not have very good judgment or discretion or he wouldn’t be a paternity suspec. i feel so sorry for little caylee. she truly lived in a house of horror.

    8. dee on March 23rd, 2009 10:07 am

      See BUN I agree with you, I would think all these “Johns” would be coming forward as well, you know for that 15 minutes of fame, unless the looser was married, as always someone is hiding, lying, we will go mad trying to figure this BS out…

    9. Charlee on March 23rd, 2009 10:39 am

      At this point who the daddy of Caylee is not important. It’s evident that Casey Anthony slept with many men. However, This Josh who died in a car crash (didn’t they know where he was buried) could be ruled out through dna through his parents. Anyways like I said, it really isn’t important. The issue now is justice for Caylee.

    10. NoseyRosey on March 23rd, 2009 11:40 am


      Do you know where I can find a pic of Mark Hawkins? This is the first time I have heard his name mentioned at all. I really thought I knew a lot about this case, but you guys know your stuff.

    11. Robin D. on March 23rd, 2009 11:52 am

      I would seek and do DNA testing on Mark Hawkins, Josh who she had the one night stand with. I would trace her cell records and any guy she texted or called since she conceived poor Caylee I’d test them (process of elemination)I would not allow the general public to get their hands on this info for protection of his privacy. Then if I were him I’d come back and sue them all for wrongful death and take all the BLOOD money back from ABC, Geraldo, Leonard, Baez, Cindy, George, and Lee. BTW does anyone else know Casey’s going to be an Aunt? I feel like writing her a letter and send it to her in jail letting her in on the GREAT news. You know she will try harder to get out of jail to go murder that baby too. She is EAT UP with jealousy…

    12. dee on March 23rd, 2009 2:08 pm

      maybe this is the answer, can we search the database and find out like this old man did?

    13. Kimm on March 23rd, 2009 2:52 pm

      Fudge the neighborhood association..This little girl deserves to have a memorial. The anthony’s need to have to drive by it everyday to see what they turned their backs on..This little girl is not and was not a burden to anyone but her mother.

    14. donna on March 23rd, 2009 4:47 pm

      i am sure she had many many one night stands.
      she must have no idea who caylee’s father was.
      she ain’t nothing but a baby murderer.
      i hope she rots in prison then burns in hell!

    15. ANewGirl on March 23rd, 2009 6:45 pm

      This probably is not going to be the most popular comment, but may I just say that I for one, really don’t care who Caylee’s Bio Dad was. Not that it was the ethical thing to do either, but obviously, Casey had numerous sexual partners or she would have been able to identify him?

      All I care about is that the damn trial finally begins so I can see the Maternal Murderer squirming in her chair. She is going down and I relish the moment.

      ***** Justice 4 Caylee ******

    16. ELAINE/CALIFORNIA on March 23rd, 2009 10:33 pm

      the next episode of this saga is that Lee’s girlfriend is due this summer…another totally tragic event…to be born into THAT family….I know it sounds very harsh….but I am DEAD serious….poor, poor baby! Talk about timing….wonder if it was planned….just to ‘REPLACE” poor little Caylee????All of these people are just beyond belief!!!

    17. Laura on March 24th, 2009 1:14 pm

      I am so tired of hearing the Anthony’s defend Casey…. When will they finally stand up for their grand child who they supposedly loved? The only one looking for justice for Caylee is the police prosecutors and hopefully the jury. People who never got to meet her or save her unlike her trashy family…. God gave that family a gift and they ALL discarded her like trash. No body waits 31 days to report a child missing not even grandparents, they was more worried about their whore daughter getting in trouble.

    18. Amber on March 24th, 2009 10:40 pm

      I just read that George Anthony has been depositing money into Casey’s jailhouse bank account!!! The b***h steals over $45,000 from you and your family and your seriously going to give her more money so she can be more comfortable in jail!!?!? What!?? How does this make sense!??!? I agree with Laura, its time for the Anthony’s to stop defending the woman who killed their granddaughter!!!! Justice for Caylee.

    19. NY;r on March 26th, 2009 10:28 pm

      The Anthony’s are sick people period. Who in their right mind would continue to enable a killer and send her money in jail..Only the Anthony family! They are scary and sick individuals who really need to go to jail also for enabling a murderer. They knew how she was and they put their own granddaughter at risk for not acting when they should.

    20. NY;r on April 11th, 2009 1:33 pm

      I think it is extremely important who the father is!!!! Could be a major reason why Caylee was murdered…If she was molested by a friend of the family or family member and was born out of incest that could be motive….There was another case like that in Florida where the father molested his daughter and she had his children, he ended up murdering two of them I believe so all avenues should be investigated, it happens.

      My personal opinion is JP chatt is the father as she looks just like him per photos on site….Who knows if she tried to pressure him if he’s the father and something happened, like Casey getting rid of her due to some kind of secret or threat,,,who knows, just a thought

    21. Loren Allen on May 3rd, 2012 3:48 am

      ..Maybe the father didn’t have any idea- nor would if the whole case was staged.. Staged around dates that were not true, witnesses that weren’t real, and a family of ‘experienced’ liars.. If I was the father, I would’ve never of known — until I did some research.. If I am not mistaken, I could be the father, and my story would sum up the only theory that was never heard… So who is the babies father..?

    Leave a Reply

    Support Scared Monkeys! make a donation.

    • NEWS (breaking news alerts or news tips)
    • Red (comments)
    • Dugga (technical issues)
    • Dana (radio show comments)
    • Klaasend (blog and forum issues)
    E-mail It